We know that the literary world is a refraction based on the author’s axiological position in relation to the content he/she represents; however, we need to recognize, as Bakhtin warns, the intense interaction there is between the world of art and the world of life. That said, this article analyzed the short story The day he came, aiming to understand the aesthetic project of the author as he represents the authoritarian discourse of heteronormative masculinity, which is present in patriarchal societies and, especially, in those where homosexuality is criminalized as is the case of Nigeria, the home country of Amatesiro Dore. The analysis revealed that the author represents the conflict between homosexuality and patriarchal religious discourse, highlighting that the authoritarian discourse of heteronormative masculinity not only oppresses people who do not follow its ideological patterns, but also creates a hierarchy in which effeminate homosexuals are oppressed by masculinized homosexuals.