Handling controversial arguments
- 1 January 2009
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Applied Non-Classical Logics
- Vol. 19 (3) , 311-369
Abstract
We present two prudent semantics within Dung's theory of arg umentation. 1 They are based on two new notions of extension, referred to as p-exten sion and c-extension. Two argu- ments cannot belong to the same p-extension whenever one of t hem attacks indirectly the other one. Two arguments cannot belong to the same c-extension whe never one of them indirectly attacks a third argument while the other one indirectly defe nds the third. We argue that our semantics lead to a better handling of controversial argume nts than Dung's ones. We compare the prudent inference relations induced by our semantics w. r.t. cautiousness; we also compare them with the inference relations induced by Dung's semanti cs.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Elements of Argumentation2008
- Computing ideal sceptical argumentationArtificial Intelligence, 2007
- SCC-recursiveness: a general schema for argumentation semanticsArtificial Intelligence, 2005
- Solving Semantic Problems with Odd-Length Cycles in Argumentation2003
- On the computational complexity of assumption-based argumentation for default reasoningArtificial Intelligence, 2002
- Inferring from Inconsistency in Preference-Based Argumentation FrameworksJournal of Automated Reasoning, 2002
- A logic-based theory of deductive arguments☆☆This is an extended version of a paper entitled “Towards a logic-based theory of argumentation” published in the Proceedings of the National Conference on Artificial Intelligence (AAAI'2000), Austin, TX, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 2000.Artificial Intelligence, 2001
- Extending abstract argumentation systems theoryArtificial Intelligence, 2000
- Graph theoretical structures in logic programs and default theoriesTheoretical Computer Science, 1996
- On the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in nonmonotonic reasoning, logic programming and n-person gamesArtificial Intelligence, 1995