Handling controversial arguments

Authors:

Abstract
We present two prudent semantics within Dung's theory of arg umentation. 1 They are based on two new notions of extension, referred to as p-exten sion and c-extension. Two argu- ments cannot belong to the same p-extension whenever one of t hem attacks indirectly the other one. Two arguments cannot belong to the same c-extension whe never one of them indirectly attacks a third argument while the other one indirectly defe nds the third. We argue that our semantics lead to a better handling of controversial argume nts than Dung's ones. We compare the prudent inference relations induced by our semantics w. r.t. cautiousness; we also compare them with the inference relations induced by Dung's semanti cs.

This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit: