Does it Pay to Send Multiple Pre-Paid Incentives? Evidence from a Randomized Experiment
Open Access
- 1 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System in Finance and Economics Discussion Series
- No. 2024-023,p. 1-23
Abstract
To encourage survey participation and improve sample representativeness, the Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) offers an unconditional pre-paid monetary incentive and separate post-paid incentive upon survey completion. We conducted a pre-registered between-subject randomized control experiment within the 2022 SCF, with at least 1,200 households per experimental group, to examine whether changing the pre-paid incentive structure affects survey outcomes. We assess the effects of: (1) altering the total dollar value of the pre-paid incentive (“incentive effect”), (2) giving two identical pre-paid incentives holding the total dollar value fixed (“reminder effect”), and (3) offering multiple pre-paid incentives of different amounts holding the total dollar value fixed (“slope effect”) on survey response rates, interviewer burden, and data quality. Our evidence indicates that a single $15 pre-paid incentive increases response rates and maintains similar levels of interviewer burden and data quality, relative to a single $5 pre-paid incentive. Splitting the $15 into two pre-paid incentives of different amounts increases interviewer burden though lengthening time in the field without improving response rates, reducing the number of contact attempts needed for a response, or improving data quality, regardless of whether the first pre-paid is larger or smaller than the second.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pre-incentive Efficacy in Survey Response Rates in a Large Prospective Military CohortField Methods, 2023
- An Experimental Evaluation of Two Approaches for Improving Response to Household Screening Efforts in National Mail/Web SurveysJournal of Survey Statistics and Methodology, 2022
- Monetary Incentives in Large-Scale Face-to-Face Surveys: Evidence from a Series of ExperimentsInternational Journal of Public Opinion Research, 2021
- What do Workplace Wellness Programs do? Evidence from the Illinois Workplace Wellness Study*The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2019
- The Effect of Large Monetary Incentives on Survey CompletionPublic Opinion Quarterly, 2017
- Effects of Sequential Prepaid Incentives and Envelope Messaging in Mail SurveysPublic Opinion Quarterly, 2015
- Surveying the General Public over the Internet Using Address-Based Sampling and Mail Contact ProceduresPublic Opinion Quarterly, 2011
- The Influence of Incremental Increases in Token Cash Incentives on Mail Survey Response: Is There an Optimal Amount?Public Opinion Quarterly, 2004
- Charities, No; Lotteries, No; Cash, Yes: Main Effects and Interactions in a Canadian Incentives ExperimentPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1996
- The interactive effects of monetary incentive justification and questionnaire length on mail survey response ratesPsychology & Marketing, 1994