A Retrospective Analysis of 3 Yearʼs Experience of an Interdisciplinary Approach to Gallstone Disease Including Shock-waves

Authors:
  • GPGustav Paumgartner
    Gustav Paumgartner
  • TSTilman Sauerbruch
    Tilman Sauerbruch
  • MSMichael Sackmann
    Michael Sackmann
  • HKHans-Jörg Krämling
    Hans-Jörg Krämling
  • MDMichael Delius
    Michael Delius
  • WBWalter Brendel
    Walter Brendel

Abstract
1206 patients with gallstone disease were treated between January 1985 and December 1987, using an interdisciplinary concept that included surgery, endoscopic sphincterotomy, and extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy (ESWL). Twenty-five per cent of the patients who were admitted for gallbladder stones were treated by ESWL, whereas 75% underwent surgery. Mortality of elective treatment for gallbladder stones amounted to 0.25% (0.4% in surgery, 0% in ESWL). Postoperative complication rate was low (4.2% in surgery, 7.0% in ESWL). After ESWL treatment, 80% of the patients were free of stones after a follow-up period of 1 year. Recurrence rate in these patients amounted up to 10%: in seven of 70 patients, mean follow-up period was 6 months after complete disappearance of stones. Twenty-seven per cent of all patients who were admitted for bile duct stones underwent surgery, whereas in the other 73%, calculi were removed via endoscopy. ESWL treatment was used additionally, if necessary. Fragments were left behind in three of 75 patients (4.0%) after surgical treatment, and in 7 of 200 patients (3.5%) after endoscopic and ESWL treatment, respectively. In the latter group, three patients (1.5%) required an additional operation. There were no deaths in either of the groups. The use of ESWL for treatment of gallbladder stones needs to be evaluated in long-term follow-up studies. Thus far, surgery remains the dominating method. Endoscopic procedures, eventually combined with ESWL, represent the preferred treatment for patients with bile duct stones.

This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit: