The Law’s Majestic Equality? The Distributive Impact of Judicializing Social and Economic Rights
Authors:
- Daniel M. BrinksDBDaniel M. Brinks
- Varun GauriVGVarun Gauri
Top Cited Papers
- 1 March 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Perspectives on Politics
- Vol. 12 (2) , 375-393
Abstract
While many find cause for optimism about the use of law and rights for progressive ends, the academic literature has long been skeptical that courts favor the poor. We show that, with the move toward a robust “new constitutionalism” of social and economic rights, the assumptions underlying the skepticism do not always hold. Our theories must account for variation in the elite bias of law and litigation. In particular, we need to pay closer attention to the broad, collective effects of legal mobilization, rather than focusing narrowly on the litigants and the direct benefits they receive. We support the claim by showing that litigation pursued in legal contexts that create the expectation of collective effects is more likely to avoid the potential anti-poor bias of courts. On the other hand, policy areas dominated by individual litigation and individualized effects are more likely to experience regressive outcomes. Using data on social and economic rights cases in four countries, we estimate the potential pro-poor impact of litigation by examining whether the poor are over- or under-represented among the beneficiaries of litigation. We find that the impact of courts is positive and very much pro-poor in India and South Africa, and slightly negative in Indonesia and Brazil. Overall, we challenge the tendency in the literature to focus on the direct effects of litigation, find that the results of litigation are more positive for the poor than the conventional wisdom would lead us to expect, and offer an explanation that accounts for part of the variation while raising a number of questions for future research.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Suing Russia at HomeProblems of Post-Communism, 2012
- Post-Communist CourtsProblems of Post-Communism, 2012
- Claiming the Right to Health in Brazilian Courts: The Exclusion of the Already Excluded?Law & Social Inquiry, 2011
- South Africa's Treatment Action Campaign: Combining Law and Social Mobilization to Realize the Right to HealthJournal of Human Rights Practice, 2009
- The Judicialization of Mega-Politics and the Rise of Political CourtsAnnual Review of Political Science, 2008
- Perfil sociodemográfico e padrão de utilização de serviços de saúde para usuários e não-usuários do SUS - PNAD 2003Ciencia & Saude Coletiva, 2006
- Judicial Policy Implementation in Mexico City and MeridaComparative Politics, 2004
- The Judicialization of Politics in IsraelInternational Political Science Review, 1994
- The Rule of Law: An Unqualified Human Good?The Yale Law Journal, 1977
- Why the “Haves” Come Out Ahead: Speculations on the Limits of Legal ChangeLaw & Society Review, 1974