Sixth-Grade Teachers’ Written Comments on Student Writing
Authors:
- 1 January 2006
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Written Communication
- Vol. 23 (1) , 36-62
Abstract
This article examines the influence of genre and gender on comments written by 108 sixth-grade teachers in response to two narrative and two persuasive papers. There were significant genre differences. Process, conventions, artistic style, and format were the focus of significantly greater numbers of comments directed to narrative writing. In contrast, meaning, organization, effort, and ideology were emphasized to a greater degree when teachers responded to persuasive writing. Teachers tended to indicate and make greater numbers of corrections and to provide more criticisms and lessons, explanations, and suggestions when the work was attributed to a male writer. Female teachers generally wrote greater numbers of comments and tended to indicate and make more corrections. Generally, teachers were reluctant to engage with the ideologies in students’ writing. There was a correlation between convention errors and the number and types of comments.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond the Red Pen: Clarifying Our Role in the Response ProcessEnglish Journal, 2000
- The Genre of the End Comment: Conventions in Teacher Responses to Student WritingCollege Composition and Communication, 1997
- Gender bias and critique of student writingAssessing Writing, 1996
- The Emergence of GenresWritten Communication, 1994
- Teachers' Rhetorical Comments on Student PapersCollege Composition and Communication, 1993
- Is Narrative “Primary”? Some Insights from Kindergarteners' Pretend Readings of Stories and Information BooksJournal of Reading Behavior, 1993
- Evaluating Competence of Women and Men: Effects of Experimenter Gender and Group Gender CompositionPsychology of Women Quarterly, 1988
- Children's Sense of GenreWritten Communication, 1985
- Responding to Student WritingCollege Composition and Communication, 1982
- Why Do Teachers Give the Grades They Do?College Composition and Communication, 1979