Which Epistemic Processes Occur When Pre-Service Teachers Reflect on Practitioners’ Misconceptions?
Open Access
- 2 March 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Education Sciences
- Vol. 15 (3) , 308
Abstract
Reflection can help pre-service teachers in practical phases to process anecdotal evidence (and possible misconceptions contained therein) appropriately for their professional development. In an exploratory approach, we analyze the think-aloud protocols of eleven pre-service teachers for primary education who reflect on anecdotal evidence. First, we examine whether and to what extent they identify and address misconceptions. Then, we use the AIR model of epistemic cognition to investigate which epistemic processes occur when pre-service teachers reflect on anecdotal evidence. Finally, through a qualitative comparison of three protocols, we explore possible connections between the use of epistemic processes and the processing of misconceptions. While all participants noticed a misconception from the field of educational sciences and dealt with it to varying degrees of proficiency, the subject-specific didactic misconception was hardly addressed despite causing irritation, and the content-specific misconception remained unnoticed. We were able to differentiate epistemic processes in the subcategories of noticing, reasoning, conclusion, and alternative actions as well as application of epistemic ideals. Pre-service teachers who recognized a misconception and elaborated on it with scientific knowledge seem to use epistemic processes differently, which is more concretely related to the given lesson plan. We discuss the results with regard to possible implications for university teacher training and further research desiderata.Keywords
Funding Information
- project ‘Kohärenz in der Lehrerbildung (KoLBi)’ [Coherence in Teacher Education] (01JA1807)
- Publication Fund for Open Access Publications of the University Library of the University of Wuppertal (01JA1807)
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- The AIR and Apt-AIR Frameworks of Epistemic Performance and Growth: Reflections on Educational Theory DevelopmentEducational Psychology Review, 2024
- Bridging domains: examining the effects of relevance instructions and guiding questions on pre-service teachers’ first- and second-order knowledge integrationInstructional Science, 2024
- Förderung evidenzorientierten Problemlösens in der Lehramtsausbildung. Effekte zweier Verfahren zur Induktion eines neutralen vs. positiven Nützlichkeitswertes2023
- Was Lehrkräfte im Unterricht getrost ignorieren können: Lernstile von Lernenden2022
- Mythen, Fehlvorstellungen, Fehlkonzepte und Irrtümer in Schule und Unterricht2022
- Pre-service teachers’ evidence-based reasoning during pedagogical problem-solving: better together?European Journal of Psychology of Education, 2020
- Misconceptions die hard: prevalence and reduction of wrong beliefs in topics from educational psychology among preservice teachersEuropean Journal of Psychology of Education, 2020
- Lautes Denken2019
- Analyzing Qualitative Data with MAXQDA2019
- Lernen aus Fehlern Zur Psychologie des „negativen“ Wissens1999