The Carnegie Elective Classification for Community Engagement provides a framework for colleges and universities to demonstrate institutional commitment to community engagement. This chapter analyzes institutional definitions across five dimensions: (1) identification of specific communities; (2) emphasis on collaborative processes; (3) articulation of mutually beneficial outcomes; (4) explicit connections to scholarship; and (5) references to critical, equity‐focused approaches. Drawing on anonymized examples from application narratives, the chapter reviews how colleges and universities articulate these elements and how they discuss the pedagogical implications for student learning. By revealing the diversity of institutional emphases, this chapter then offers recommendations for campus leaders and community engagement professionals to refine community‐based learning opportunities. Intentionally defining community engagement can enhance student learning by linking academic content to real‐world challenges, fostering reciprocity, and empowering students as active civic participants.