Unpacking Environmental Assessment Reports: Power, Discourse, and Policy Implications in North Kendeng Mountain, Indonesia
Author:
- 27 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Asian Politics & Policy
- Vol. 18 (1)
Abstract
This article examines the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), EIA Addendum, and Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) used to evaluate the Watuputih Groundwater Basin in the designated karst area of North Kendeng Mountain, planned for cement mining. Using discourse analysis of systematic language and text, it compares the narratives and framings within these documents. The analysis reveals a complex relationship between dominant and alternative discourses. The dominant policy discourse, reflected in the EIA and its addendum, is shaped by powerful actors such as cement companies and the Central Java provincial government, who explicitly prioritize economic development. In contrast, the alternative discourse, represented in the SEA, promotes a more sustainable approach to governing the karst landscape. This contrast highlights competing environmental governance paradigms and the political role of environmental assessments. Ultimately, the study shows how key actors influence public perception and policy direction through competing knowledge claims embedded in environmental assessment frameworks.Keywords
This publication has 59 references indexed in Scilit:
- Winning the discursive struggle? The impact of a significant environmental crisis event on dominant climate discourses on TwitterDiscourse, Context & Media, 2022
- Effective Community Engagement during the Environmental Assessment of a Mining Project in the Canadian ArcticEnvironmental Management, 2021
- Using the Framework for Integrated Sustainability Assessment (FISA) to expand the Multiregional Input–Output analysis to account for the three pillars of sustainabilityEnvironment, Development and Sustainability, 2016
- Challenging dominant discourses of climate changeClimatic Change, 2014
- Public Hearing or ‘Hearing Public’? An Evaluation of the Participation of Local Stakeholders in Environmental Impact Assessment of Ghana’s Jubilee Oil FieldsEnvironmental Management, 2013
- A Framework for Fully Integrating Environmental AssessmentEnvironmental Management, 2008
- Public and stakeholder participation in European water policy: a critical review of project evaluation processesEuropean Environment, 2006
- Regulatory impact assessment and regulatory governance in developing countriesPublic Administration and Development, 2004
- Practitioner Perspectives on the Role of Science in Environmental Impact AssessmentEnvironmental Management, 2003
- The Assessment of Cumulative Environmental Impacts in EIA and Land-Use Planning1998