A theoretical and empirical analysis of tensions between learning objects and constructivism
Open Access
- 12 June 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Education and Information Technologies
- Vol. 30 (15) , 22101-22150
Abstract
Learning Objects (LOs) have long aimed to make digital education scalable and reusable, yet their alignment with constructivist learning remains contested. This study offers a structured comparison of traditional LO design principles and constructivist learning metaphors—acquisition, participation, and knowledge creation—to examine how emerging research directions position themselves within this educational technology landscape. We analyse how emerging research directions—symbolic AI, generative AI, hybrid AI (Retrieval-Augmented Generation), and constructivist-oriented LO research—align with or challenge these learning metaphors. We then explore how these directions influence the relationship between LOs and constructivist pedagogy. Our findings show that while some AI-based approaches reinforce structured, predefined learning, others—and especially constructivist-oriented LO models—support more adaptive, collaborative, and student-centred designs. Empirical findings from teacher interviews reveal that teachers’ conceptions of learning vary by context—often defaulting to transmissive models under technological constraints, but aligning more closely with participation and knowledge creation metaphors when reflecting on pedagogical theory. These combined and somewhat surprising findings underscore the need for LO frameworks that are pedagogically flexible—that is, able to support both structured and open-ended designs, adapt to varying teaching contexts, and empower learners through meaningful engagement.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of South-Eastern Norway
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Exploring the perceived benefits and drawbacks of using multimodal learning objects in pre-service English teacher inverted instructionEducation and Information Technologies, 2020
- Design, development and evaluation of open interactive learning objects for secondary school physical educationEducation and Information Technologies, 2020
- From Digital Learning Resources to Adaptive Learning Objects: An Overview2020
- ACT‐R: A cognitive architecture for modeling cognitionWIREs Cognitive Science, 2018
- Professional development learning environments (PDLEs) embedded in a collaborative online learning environment (COLE): Moving towards a new conception of online professional learningEducation and Information Technologies, 2018
- Does Active Learning Work? A Review of the ResearchJournal of Engineering Education, 2004
- The trouble with learning objectsEducational Technology Research and Development, 2004
- Categorisation in Knowledge Building2003
- Understanding of number concepts in low attaining 7?9 year olds: Part I. Development of descriptive framework and diagnostic instrumentEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1986
- Inadequacies of the Computer Metaphor1984