Measuring What Converts: Identification Limits of the European Regional Innovation Data
Preprint
- 31 August 2026
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
The Regional Innovation Scoreboard is the principal evidence base for European regional innovation policy, and a substantial applied literature estimates econometric models on it. This paper asks a prior question: what can that source identify? Using the commercialisation of novelty as a demonstration case — the sales of new-to-market and new-to-firm innovations across 218 European regions over four Community Innovation Survey waves — we establish three boundaries. First, the published annual file is not an annual dataset: biennial survey values are replicated across the reference years each wave covers, so the nominal eight-year panel contains four independent observations per region. Collapsing to survey waves changes standard errors on the annually varying registry indicators by up to forty per cent and reverses one coefficient sign. Second, the cross-sectional and longitudinal dimensions of the source do not agree. A Mundlak decomposition reveals a complete sign reversal for the leading regressor, negative between regions and strongly positive within them, and leave-one-country-out validation returns negative out-of-sample fit for every learner, locating much of the between variation in national measurement regime rather than economic behaviour. Third, flexible learners outperform the linear specification under conventional cross-validation but cease to do so under leakage-free panel designs. Within these boundaries the substantive picture is narrow: of seven innovation inputs only SME product-innovation incidence and trademark activity are associated with innovative revenue, and a taxonomy of innovation modes derived net of performance level proves nearly orthogonal to the official classification. The Scoreboard supports longitudinal inference about a region's own trajectory, not the cross-sectional benchmarking it was designed to invite.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2026-08-31, Preprints
- Published version: Systems, 14 (11), 1415.
This publication has 226 references indexed in Scilit:
- Business innovation modes in China’s firms: Technological swing and the value of social capitalJournal of Evolutionary Economics, 2026
- Innovation modes in the peripheral economyJournal of Evolutionary Economics, 2026
- Geographical Location, Green Technology Commercialization, and Sustainable InnovationSustainable Development, 2025
- Private equity acquisitions and product market decisions: Evidence from trademarksReview of Financial Economics, 2025
- Innovation and digitalisation in European regions: addressing spatial issues through GWR-SAR approachAnnals of Operations Research, 2025
- Patent value indicators and technological innovationEmpirical Economics, 2021
- Introducing goods innovation, service innovation, or both? Investigating the tension in managing innovation revenue streams for manufacturing and service firmsJournal of Operations Management, 2021
- Converting inventions into innovations in large firms: How inventors at Xerox navigated the innovation process to commercialize their ideasStrategic Management Journal, 2020
- Collaborative innovation in emerging innovation systems: Evidence from Central and Eastern EuropeThe Journal of Technology Transfer, 2020
- Comparing partitionsJournal of Classification, 1985