Exploring Prospective Teachers’ Ability to Generate and Analyze Evidence-based Explanatory Arguments
Open Access
- 30 March 2020
- journal article
- Published by ISTES Organization in International Journal of Research in Education and Science
- Vol. 6 (2) , 327-346
Abstract
In this paper, using written responses of 37 PSTs preparing to teach grades 1-8 mathematics, we examined explanations they constructed to support their problem solutions and explanations they provided in support of their critiques of student-generated explanations. We also examined features of explanations on which PSTs drew in their critiques of mathematical explanations of students. Our results draw attention to the importance of helping PSTs develop competencies in constructing and critiquing mathematical explanations concurrently. Although explanations PSTs generated for their critiques of student explanations were weaker compared to the explanations PSTs formulated for their own problem solutions, PSTs proficient in generating mathematical explanations were also more proficient in analyzing and critiquing mathematical explanations. We identified seven criteria PSTs used while analyzing and critiquing student-explanations. These criteria reveal what PSTs might value, or pay attention to, as they critique student-explanations. We share implications for mathematics teacher educators to consider and suggest directions for further research.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reasoning-and-proving opportunities in elementary mathematics textbooksInternational Journal of Educational Research, 2014
- JUSTIFICATIONS AND EXPLANATIONS IN ISRAELI 7TH GRADE MATH TEXTBOOKSInternational Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2013
- Providing written feedback on students’ mathematical arguments: proof validations of prospective secondary mathematics teachersJournal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 2013
- Exploring one student’s explanations at different ages: the case of SharonEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2012
- ‘Warrant’ revisited: Integrating mathematics teachers’ pedagogical and epistemological considerations into Toulmin’s model for argumentationEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2011
- Modes of reasoning in explanations in Australian eighth-grade mathematics textbooksEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2009
- CREATING OPTIMAL MATHEMATICS LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS: COMBINING ARGUMENTATION AND WRITING TO ENHANCE ACHIEVEMENTInternational Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 2008
- A method for revealing structures of argumentations in classroom proving processesZDM – Mathematics Education, 2008
- Challenges in deepening prospective teachers’ understanding of multiplication through justificationJournal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 2007
- Preservice teachers’ knowledge of proof by mathematical inductionJournal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 2007