Comparison between Weibull and gamma distributions to derive synthetic unit hydrograph using Horton ratios
- 22 April 2008
- journal article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 44 (4)
Abstract
The two‐parameter Weibull distribution (2PWD), similar to an instantaneous unit hydrograph (IUH), is parameterized in terms of Horton catchment ratios on the basis of a geomorphologic model of catchment response. For this the shape and scale parameters of the Weibull distribution are expressed analytically in terms of Horton's catchment ratios. The two parameters of the IUH derived using Nash's model, which is a two‐parameter gamma distribution (2PGD), are also expressed analytically in terms of Horton ratios. The performance of the proposed methods is tested for describing a synthetic unit hydrograph (SUH) under limited data conditions. A comparison is made with the unit hydrographs derived from the event data of two real catchments, and with the existing geomorphological based 2PGD for developing SUH given by Rosso (1984). The sensitivity analysis of the 2PWD to the nondimensional parameter β of the UH (a product of peak discharge and time to peak) shows β to be more sensitive to the shape parameter a than the scale parameter b. Further examination to find any similarity between the behavior of 2PWD and 2PGD showed that a in 2PWD corresponds to the shape parameter n in the 2PGD, and b behaves similar to the scale parameter k in the 2PGD. Finally, practical applicability of the proposed approach to ungauged catchments is tested using field data.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Suitability of Gamma, Chi-square, Weibull, and Beta distributions as synthetic unit hydrographsJournal of Hydrology, 2007
- Discussion of “Simplified Two-Parameter Gamma Distribution for Derivation of Synthetic Unit Hydrograph” by P. K. Bhunya, S. K. Mishra, and Ronny BerndtssonJournal of Hydrologic Engineering, 2005
- Parameter Estimation of Beta Distribution for Unit Hydrograph DerivationJournal of Hydrologic Engineering, 2004
- A geomorphological explanation of the unit hydrograph conceptHydrological Processes, 2004
- Simplified Two-Parameter Gamma Distribution for Derivation of Synthetic Unit HydrographJournal of Hydrologic Engineering, 2003
- On the parametric approach to unit hydrograph identificationWater Resources Management, 1989
- Unit hydrographs via nonlinear programingWater Resources Research, 1982
- The geomorphologic structure of hydrologic responseWater Resources Research, 1979
- Computation of optimum realizable unit hydrographsWater Resources Research, 1966
- Systematic determination of unit hydrograph parametersJournal of Geophysical Research, 1959