Features of foreign policy birds: Israeli prime ministers as hawks and doves
Author:
- 31 May 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Cooperation and Conflict
- Vol. 55 (1) , 107-126
Abstract
Scholars and policymakers have long used the shorthand of hawks and doves to characterize leader personalities that correspond to a particular political inclination, whereby hawks are considered right-wing and more aggressive in foreign policy, and doves are left-wing and more peaceful. This article posits that a sound discussion of who hawks and doves in foreign policy are requires an engagement with research on political leadership. It promises a less superficial understanding of the dichotomy of hawks and doves, and uses leadership trait analysis to explore hawkish and dovish leaders’ qualities. The article profiles Israel’s prime ministers since the end of the Cold War, where in a high security environment, these words are most often used to describe its domestic and foreign matters and its cooperative and conflictual actions. This article’s findings encourage an unpacking of these commonly used shorthand labels with political leadership approaches. They are also useful to highlight, most notably, the significance of complexity and distrust in understanding hawkish and dovish leaders. Hawks think simpler and are more doubtful of others than doves, this article finds. Future research, the article suggests, will benefit from looking deeper than simple, dichotomous use of this analogy, and exploring ways to operationalize individual-level measurements of hawks and doves in foreign policy.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cognitive Structure and Foreign Policy Change: Israel’s Decision to Talk to the PLOInternational Relations, 2011
- Personality Foundations of Ideological Divide: A Comparison of Women Members of Parliament and Women Voters in ItalyPolitical Psychology, 2010
- “Quasi Track-One” Diplomacy: An Analysis of the Geneva Process in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict1International Studies Perspectives, 2010
- Germans as Venutians: The Culture of German Foreign Policy BehaviorForeign Policy Analysis, 2006
- Israeli Foreign Policy under Right-Wing Governments: A Constructivist InterpretationIsrael Studies Forum, 2004
- Extending the Three‐ and Four‐Headed Eagles: The Foreign Policy Orientations of American Elites During the 80s and 90sPolitical Psychology, 1997
- Domestic Political Systems and War PronenessMershon International Studies Review, 1994
- The Cognitive Structure of Peacemaking: Egypt and Israel, 1970-1978Political Psychology, 1992
- Doves, Hawks, and other Birds of a Feather: The Distribution of Israeli Parliamentary Opinion on the Future of the Occupied Territories, 1967–1977British Journal of Political Science, 1980
- Psychological constructs in foreign policy predictionJournal of Conflict Resolution, 1967