Accurate prediction equations for ventilatory thresholds in cardiometabolic disease when gas exchange analysis is unavailable: development and validation
Authors:
- Juliana Goulart Prata Oliveira MilaniJMJuliana Goulart Prata Oliveira Milani
- Mauricio MilaniMMMauricio Milani
- Felipe Vilaça Cavallari MachadoFMFelipe Vilaça Cavallari Machado
- Matthias WilhelmMWMatthias Wilhelm
- Thimo MarcinTMThimo Marcin
- Flavio D’aScenziFlavio D’aScenzi
- Luna CavigliLuna Cavigli
- Charly KeytsmanCKCharly Keytsman
- Maarten FalterMFMaarten Falter
- Bruno BonnechereBruno Bonnechere
- Raf MeesenRMRaf Meesen
- Fabrício BragaFBFabrício Braga
- 18 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in European Journal of Preventive Cardiology
- Vol. 31 (16) , 1914-1924
Abstract
Aims: To develop and validate equations predicting heart rate (HR) at the first and second ventilatory thresholds (VTs) and an optimized range-adjusted prescription for patients with cardiometabolic disease (CMD). To compare their performance against guideline-based exercise intensity domains. Methods and results: Cross-sectional study involving 2868 CMD patients from nine countries. HR predictive equations for first and second VTs (VT1, VT2) were developed using multivariate linear regression with 975 cycle-ergometer cardiopulmonary exercise tests (CPET). ‘Adjusted’ percentages of peak HR (%HRpeak) and HR reserve (%HRR) were derived from this group. External validation with 1893 CPET (cycle-ergometer or treadmill) assessed accuracy, agreement, and reliability against guideline-based %HRpeak and %HRR prescriptions using mean absolute percentage error (MAPE), Bland–Altman analyses, intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC). HR predictive equations (R²: 0.77 VT1, 0.88 VT2) and adjusted %HRR (VT1: 42%, VT2: 77%) were developed. External validation demonstrated superiority over widely used guideline-directed intensity domains for %HRpeak and %HRR. The new methods showed consistent performance across both VTs with lower MAPE (VT1: 7.1%, VT2: 5.0%), ‘good’ ICC for VT1 (0.81, 0.82) and ‘excellent’ for VT2 (0.93). Guideline-based exercise intensity domains had higher MAPE (VT1: 6.8–21.3%, VT2: 5.1–16.7%), ‘poor’ to ‘good’ ICC for VT1, and ‘poor’ to ‘excellent’ for VT2, indicating inconsistencies related to specific VTs across guidelines. Conclusion: Developed and validated HR predictive equations and the optimized %HRR for CMD patients for determining VT1 and VT2 outperformed the guideline-based exercise intensity domains and showed ergometer interchangeability. They offer a superior alternative for prescribing moderate intensity exercise when CPET is unavailable.Keywords
Funding Information
- Special Research Fund (BOF23DOCBL10, BOF23KV10)
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Standardised Exercise Prescription for Patients with Chronic Coronary Syndrome and/or Heart Failure: A Consensus Statement from the EXPERT Working GroupSports Medicine, 2023
- Do Clinical Exercise Tests Permit Exercise Threshold Identification in Patients Referred to Cardiac Rehabilitation?Canadian Journal of Cardiology, 2023
- Updated Reference Standards for Cardiorespiratory Fitness Measured with Cardiopulmonary Exercise TestingMayo Clinic Proceedings, 2022
- The role of cardiac rehabilitation in improving cardiovascular outcomesNature Reviews Cardiology, 2021
- An Examination and Critique of Current Methods to Determine Exercise IntensitySports Medicine, 2020
- Impact of Exercise Rehabilitation on Exercise Capacity and Quality-of-Life in Heart FailureJACC, 2019
- Adipose tissue lipolytic inhibition enhances the glucoregulatory properties of exercise in type 2 diabetes patientsEuropean Journal of Sport Science, 2018
- Electrical support during outdoor cycling in patients with coronary artery disease: impact on exercise intensity, volume and perception of effortActa Cardiologica, 2017
- Cardiopulmonary Exercise TestingJACC, 2017
- A Guideline of Selecting and Reporting Intraclass Correlation Coefficients for Reliability ResearchJournal of Chiropractic Medicine, 2016