Commercial Overfishing and Property Rights

Author:

Abstract
Management of many commercial fisheries includes a struggle to avoid overfishing. Natural resource agencies fail in this struggle when the application of biological, sociological, or philosophical sciences fails. In addition, they fail because they underestimate the pervasiveness of greed and the power of commerce, not because they lack good intentions. Current strategies to manage commercial fishing include extending property rights for fish harvests. The objective of this paper is to stimulate debate on the need—and consequences—of extending property rights to wild, exploitable fish populations as opposed to granting harvest rights. The question is, If property rights for fish were awarded to nonfishing, nongovernmental entities that then sell fishing rights to harvesters and help manage fish stocks, would this system be more likely to produce sustainable harvests and benefits? Strategies to achieve sustainable wild fish benefits are many and diverse. Should we explore extending property rights...