Reality check: the cost–effectiveness of removing body checking from youth ice hockey
- 6 June 2014
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in British Journal of Sports Medicine
- Vol. 48 (17) , 1299-1305
Abstract
Background/aim The risk of injury among Pee Wee (ages 11–12 years) ice hockey players in leagues that allow body checking is threefold greater than in leagues that do not allow body checking. We estimated the cost–effectiveness of a no body checking policy versus a policy that allows body checking in Pee Wee ice hockey. Methods Cost–effectiveness analysis alongside a prospective cohort study during the 2007–2008 season, including players in Quebec (n=1046), where policy did not allow body checking, and in Alberta (n=1108), where body checking was allowed. Injury incidence rates (injuries/1000 player-hours) and incidence proportions (injuries/100 players), adjusted for cluster using Poisson regression, allowed for standardised comparisons and meaningful translation to community stakeholders. Based on Alberta fee schedules, direct healthcare costs (physician visits, imaging, procedures) were adjusted for cluster using bootstrapping. We examined uncertainty in our estimates using cost–effectiveness planes. Results Associated with significantly higher injury rates, healthcare costs where policy allowed body checking were over 2.5 times higher than where policy disallowed body checking ($C473/1000 player-hours (95% CI $C358 to $C603) vs $C184/1000 player-hours (95% CI $C120 to $C257)). The difference in costs between provinces was $C289/1000 player-hours (95% CI $C153 to $C432). Projecting results onto Alberta Pee Wee players registered in the 2011–2012 season, an estimated 1273 injuries and $C213 280 in healthcare costs would be avoided during just one season with the policy change. Conclusion Our study suggests that a policy disallowing body checking in Pee Wee ice hockey is cost-saving (associated with fewer injuries and lower costs) compared to a policy allowing body checking. As we did not account for long-term outcomes, our results underestimate the economic impact of these injuries.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Risk of Injury Associated With Body Checking Among Youth Ice Hockey PlayersJAMA, 2010
- Intentional versus unintentional contact as a mechanism of injury in youth ice hockeyBritish Journal of Sports Medicine, 2010
- Risk factors for injury and severe injury in youth ice hockey: a systematic review of the literatureInjury Prevention, 2010
- Effects of Changing Body-Checking Rules on Rates of Injury in Minor HockeyPediatrics, 2010
- A Systematic Review of the Association Between Body Checking and Injury in Youth Ice HockeyClinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 2009
- Injury Rates, Risk Factors, and Mechanisms of Injury in Minor HockeyThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2006
- Are cost of injury studies useful?Injury Prevention, 2000
- Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction and the Long Term Incidence of GonarthrosisSports Medicine, 1999
- Injuries in Youth Ice Hockey: A Pilot Surveillance StrategyMayo Clinic Proceedings, 1995
- Fate of the ACL-injured PatientThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1994