What is the significance of the intuition that laws of nature govern?1
Author:
- 1 June 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Australasian Journal of Philosophy
- Vol. 85 (2) , 307-324
Abstract
Recently, proponents of Humean Supervenience have challenged the plausibility of the intuition that the laws of nature ‘govern’, or guide, the evolution of events in the universe. Certain influential thought experiments authored by John Carroll, Michael Tooley, and others, rely strongly on such intuitions. These thought experiments are generally regarded as playing a central role in the lawhood debate, suggesting that the Mill-Ramsey-Lewis view of the laws of nature, and the related doctrine of the Humean Supervenience of laws, are false. In this paper, I take on these recent challenges, arguing that the intuition that the laws govern should be taken seriously. Still, I find the recent discussions insightful, in certain ways. Employing some ideas from one of the critics (Barry Loewer), I draw some non-standard conclusions about the significance of the thought experiments to the lawhood debate.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Metaphysics Within Physics2007
- David Lewis's Humean Theory of Objective ChancePhilosophy of Science, 2004
- The Non-Governing Conception of Laws of NaturePhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 2000
- Lewis, Carroll, and seeing through the looking glassAustralasian Journal of Philosophy, 1998
- Symposium: Chance and CredenceMind, 1994
- All God Has to DoAnalysis, 1991
- The Humean TraditionPhilosophical Review, 1990
- The Nature of LawsCanadian Journal of Philosophy, 1977