The neuropsychological impacts of supratotal glioma resection: A systematic review

Authors:

Abstract
Background: Supratotal resection (SpTR) has emerged as a compelling surgical target for gliomas, with a strong signal toward improved survival. However, the balance between resections extending into tumor-infiltrated normal brain and preservation of higher-order cognitive function remains poorly defined. This systematic review aims to characterize formal neuropsychological (NP) outcomes following glioma SpTR. Methods: A PRISMA-adherent systematic search was conducted across six electronic databases. Inclusion criteria required patients with WHO Grade 2-4 gliomas undergoing SpTR with standardized NP assessment. Quality was assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Critical Appraisal Checklists. Results: Fifty-five studies reported SpTR for glioma, but only 11 (20%) utilized formal NP testing as an outcome. 80% of studies omitting NP testing focused exclusively on high-grade glioma (HGG). Cognitive data was available from 2 studies in HGG and 9 studies in LGG. Early post-operative cognitive declines were reported in 55.5% of extractable cohorts, predominantly in the domains of executive function and memory/learning. The majority of these studies report cognitive recovery after 3-6 months. Long-term permanent cognitive morbidity was indeed very low (∼1%), but critical appraisal revealed a high risk of bias. Conclusions: While current evidence suggests SpTR is functionally safe, these findings are limited by high risk of bias and a lack of comparative controls. A reporting gap remains in functional-cognitive outcomes after HGG surgery. Standardized, anatomically anchored NP testing will be essential to validate the “onco-functional balance” of supratotal margins.

This publication has 86 references indexed in Scilit: