Introduction: Retention of cognitive knowledge and skill ability is a recognized challenge in all disciplines of health care. It is generally agreed that knowledge and skills decay over time. Many refresher-training programs for emergency medical services (EMS) personnel are offered in two-year cycles. Strategies based on the analysis of knowledge and skill decay over time can be used to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of refresher training programs. Hypothesis: In the absence of refresher training, knowledge and skills necessary for emergency management of acute myocardial infarction (AMI) will persistently decline over time. Methods: A retrospective analysis was conducted of pre- and post-test data collected over a five-year period (January 5, 1999, to March 9, 2004) from a randomized set of learners enrolled in our emergency management of AMI training program. The difference between initial post-test and next pre-test score was compared with the interval between trainings. Practicing paramedic learners were grouped into 180-day intervals for comparison and correlation. Results: The scores from 168 learners were evaluated. The average cognitive declines out of a possible 100 points for the shortest interval (180 days) and the longest interval (1,825 days) were 22.00 and 21.15, respectively. This was not statistically significant. There was no correlation in the average decline of knowledge and skill and the time interval between initial and refresher training (r = −0.05367). Conclusion: Decline in knowledge and skill for emergency management of AMI occurs less than 180 days after initial training and reaches a nadir that remains stable over five years. Educators should evaluate and determine the knowledge and skills that are most likely to decline over time and use this information to redesign refresher-training programs. Knowledge and skill content that remains stable over time may be reduced or eliminated from refresher programs so more focus is dedicated to “decay-prone” competencies. This has tremendous implications on the development and implementation of training programs, as it has the potential to lead to more efficient programs of study.