Reliability of distance estimation by doctors and patients: cross sectional study
Authors:
Abstract
Objective: To assess the reliability and accuracy of distance estimated by doctors and patients. Design: Comparison between estimated and measured distances of six familiar sites around Guy's Hospital, London. Subjects: 100 hospital consultants and 100 patients. Main outcome measures: Median (range) of estimated distances, and mean (SD) of the difference between estimated and measured distances. Results: Both doctors and patients gave a wide range of estimates of distance. The estimates differed by up to 14.6-fold from the measured distances, and the difference between minimum and maximum estimates was up to 62.5-fold. Conclusion: Doctors and patients were inaccurate at estimating distances, which implies that estimates of distances walked are not reliable indicators of a person's health. Key messages: Doctors and patients are inaccurate at estimating distances Estimates of distance can differ by up to 14.6-fold from measured distances, and the difference between the minimum and maximum estimates can be up to 62.5-fold When estimates are expressed as a percentage of the measured distances, estimates for shorter distances are more inaccurate than those of longer distances Decisions regarding health based on estimates of distance are unreliable The economic implication of estimating distance is considerableKeywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Intramuscular interferon beta‐1a for disease progression in relapsing multiple sclerosisAnnals of Neurology, 1996
- Clinical scales for multiple sclerosisJournal of the Neurological Sciences, 1996
- Interferon beta‐lb in the treatment of multiple sclerosisNeurology, 1995
- Reanalysis of the 12-Minute Walk in Patients With Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary DiseaseChest, 1994
- The new disability living allowance.Archives of Disease in Childhood, 1993
- Applying for disability living allowance.BMJ, 1992
- Rating neurologic impairment in multiple sclerosisNeurology, 1983
- Individual Differences in Distance Estimation: Comparison of Judgments in the Field with Those from Projected Slides of the Same ScenesPerceptual and Motor Skills, 1983
- Controlled trial of supervised exercise training in chronic bronchitis.BMJ, 1980