Tactics, traditions and opportunities: British and French crop‐trashing actions in comparative perspective
- 1 June 2012
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Political Research
- Vol. 51 (4) , 540-562
Abstract
This article compares the tactic of trashing genetically modified crops in activist campaigns in Britain and France. In Britain, most crop trashing was carried out covertly, while in France most activists undertook open, public actions. In seeking an explanation for this, the article shows that the analysis of political opportunities, dominant in comparative studies of social movements, can only take us so far. While it helps explain the occurrence of direct action, it is much less useful in explaining the tactical differences between each country. It is argued that a fuller explanation requires an understanding of how action was shaped by different activist traditions. In France, action was staged as a demonstration of serious, responsible, collective Republican citizenship; in the United Kingdom, activists combined a sceptical view of legality developing from anarchist individualism with an explicitly non‐threatening, playful, ethos. The article concludes that a focus on activist traditions can provide an effective bridge between structural and cultural approaches to understanding the determinants of social movement action.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Consensual NIMBYs, Contentious NIABYs: Explaining Contrasting Forms of Farmers GMO Opposition in Austria and FranceSociologia Ruralis, 2008
- Understanding Meaning in Movements: A Hermeneutic Approach to Frames and IdeologiesSocial Movement Studies, 2008
- Double‐edged swords? Collective identity and solidarity in the environment movement1The British Journal of Sociology, 2008
- Covert repertoires: Ecotage in the UK1Social Movement Studies, 2004
- Conceptualizing Political OpportunitySocial Forces, 2004
- “Get up, Stand up”: Tactical Repertoires of Social Movements2004
- PM Speech: 'Science Matters'IUBMB Life, 2002
- From Scientific Risk To Paysan Savoir-Faire: Peasant Expertise in the French and Global Debate over GM CropsScience as Culture, 2002
- France: broadening precautionary expertise?Journal of Risk Research, 2000
- Interest Groups and Public Policy: The Insider/Outsider Model RevisitedJournal of Public Policy, 1994