Management of the Difficult Airway: An Appraisal of Clinical Practice Guidelines
- 4 August 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery
- Vol. 170 (1) , 112-121
Abstract
Objective: Management of the difficult airway can be a challenging process, which necessitates actionable recommendations from well‐established guidelines. Herein, clinical practice guideline (CPG) quality is evaluated using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) instrument.Study Design: A systematic literature search was performed using Scopus, EMBASE, and MEDLINE via PubMed.Setting: Literature database.Methods: Data were abstracted from relevant guidelines and appraised by 4 expert reviewers in the 6 domains of quality defined by AGREE II. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC) were calculated across domains to quantify interrater reliability.Results: Twelve guidelines met the inclusion criteria. With a mean quality score of 83.1%, the highest quality guideline was authored by the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA). Low‐quality content was observed in CPGs authored by the Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists (JSA) and the Chinese Collaboration Group for Emergency Airway Management (CCGEAM). Overall, deficits were most pronounced in domains describing the involvement of stakeholders, developmental rigor, and editorial independence. These findings were consistent among the panel of independent reviewers, with high ICC inter‐rater reliability scores of 58.0% to 70.0% for the referenced domains.Conclusion: By providing a comprehensive appraisal of guidelines, this report may serve as a reference for clinicians seeking to understand and improve upon the developmental quality of difficult airway management resources. According to AGREE II criteria for the quality of the guideline creation process, the 2022 ASA guideline outperforms its predecessors.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- JSA airway management guideline 2014: to improve the safety of induction of anesthesiaJournal of Anesthesia, 2014
- Practice Guidelines for Management of the Difficult AirwayAnesthesiology, 2013
- Multidisciplinary Team Approach in the Management of Tracheostomy PatientsOtolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, 2012
- Difficult Airway Society Guidelines for the management of tracheal extubationAnaesthesia, 2012
- Can we make airway management (even) safer? – lessons from national auditAnaesthesia, 2011
- Need for Emergency Surgical Airway Reduced by a Comprehensive Difficult Airway ProgramAnesthesia & Analgesia, 2009
- A documented previous difficult tracheal intubation as a prognostic test for a subsequent difficult tracheal intubation in adultsAnaesthesia, 2009
- The Presence of an Emergency Airway Response Team and Its Effects on In-Hospital Code BlueThe Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2009
- A systematic review of appraisal tools for clinical practice guidelines: multiple similarities and one common deficitInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care, 2005
- Preoperative assessment for difficult intubation in general and ENT surgery: predictive value of a clinical multivariate risk indexBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 1998