Tensions in Informed Self-Assessment: How the Desire for Feedback and Reticence to Collect and Use It Can Conflict
Authors:
- Karen MannKMKaren Mann
- Cees van der VleutenCVCees van der Vleuten
- Kevin EvaKEKevin Eva
- Heather ArmsonHAHeather Armson
- Ben CheslukBCBen Chesluk
- Timothy DornanTDTimothy Dornan
- Eric HolmboeEHEric Holmboe
- Jocelyn LockyerJLJocelyn Lockyer
- Elaine LoneyELElaine Loney
- Joan SargeantJSJoan Sargeant
- 1 September 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Academic Medicine
- Vol. 86 (9) , 1120-1127
Abstract
Informed self-assessment describes the set of processes through which individuals use external and internal data to generate an appraisal of their own abilities. The purpose of this project was to explore the tensions described by learners and professionals when informing their self-assessments of clinical performance. This 2008 qualitative study was guided by principles of grounded theory. Eight programs in five countries across undergraduate, postgraduate, and continuing medical education were purposively sampled. Seventeen focus groups were held (134 participants). Detailed analyses were conducted iteratively to understand themes and relationships. Participants experienced multiple tensions in informed self-assessment. Three categories of tensions emerged: within people (e.g., wanting feedback, yet fearing disconfirming feedback), between people (e.g., providing genuine feedback yet wanting to preserve relationships), and in the learning/practice environment (e.g., engaging in authentic self-assessment activities versus “playing the evaluation game”). Tensions were ongoing, contextual, and dynamic; they prevailed across participant groups, infusing all components of informed self-assessment. They also were present in varied contexts and at all levels of learners and practicing physicians. Multiple tensions, requiring ongoing negotiation and renegotiation, are inherent in informed self-assessment. Tensions are both intraindividual and interindividual and they are culturally situated, reflecting both professional and institutional influences. Social learning theories (social cognitive theory) and sociocultural theories of learning (situated learning and communities of practice) may inform our understanding and interpretation of the study findings. The findings suggest that educational interventions should be directed at individual, collective, and institutional cultural levels. Implications for practice are presented.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Feedback data sources that inform physician self-assessmentMedical Teacher, 2011
- State of the science in health professional education: effective feedbackMedical Education, 2009
- ‘It’s a cultural expectation…’ The pressure on medical trainees to work independently in clinical practiceMedical Education, 2009
- Preserving professional credibility: grounded theory study of medical trainees' requests for clinical supportBMJ, 2009
- “I'll never play professional football” and other fallacies of self-assessmentJournal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 2008
- Self-monitoring in clinical practice: A challenge for medical educatorsJournal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 2008
- “Directed” self-assessment: Practice and feedback within a social contextJournal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions, 2008
- Understanding the influence of emotions and reflection upon multi-source feedback acceptance and useAdvances in Health Sciences Education, 2006
- Accuracy of Physician Self-assessment Compared With Observed Measures of CompetenceJAMA, 2006
- Flawed Self-AssessmentPsychological Science in the Public Interest, 2004