Tracing intuitive judgement of experts in fish stock assessment data
Authors:
Open Access
- 26 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Fish and Fisheries
- Vol. 23 (3) , 758-767
Abstract
Scientific advice is increasingly used to inform policy. Often, experts are asked to give advice when stakes are high, time pressure is severe and uncertainty looms. In such environments, decisions may be guided by instincts and priors, rather than reason. Yet, the extent of these intuitive judgements is unknown. We use a database of fish stock assessments to detect and quantify the systematic tendency to put too much weight on previous information, known as anchoring, in scientific advice. By exploiting exogenous variation in procedures and possibilities to vary model assumptions, we find consistent evidence for intuitive judgement. We find that anchoring is strongest if model choices are flexible and the fish stock is in crisis, potentially increasing pressure and stakes. By providing advice that is biased towards previous results, the stock assessments may be more robust but may also give a false sense of security as more drastic changes may go undetected.Keywords
Funding Information
- H2020 Marie Skłodowska-Curie Actions (675997)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preventing the collapse of the Baltic cod stock through an ecosystem-based management approachProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2009
- Finding the signal in the noise: objective data-selection criteria improve the assessment of western Baltic spring-spawning herringICES Journal of Marine Science, 2009
- Biased stock assessment when using multiple, hardly overlapping, tuning series if fishing trends vary spatiallyICES Journal of Marine Science, 2009
- Conditions for intuitive expertise: A failure to disagree.American Psychologist, 2009
- Precisely wrong or vaguely right: simulations of noisy discard data and trends in fishing effort being included in the stock assessment of North Sea plaiceICES Journal of Marine Science, 2007
- Are forecasters reluctant to revise their predictions? Some German evidenceJournal of Forecasting, 2006
- Analysis of vessel influence on spatial behaviour of fish schools using a multi-beam sonar and consequences for biomass estimates by echo-sounderICES Journal of Marine Science, 1996
- Forecasting Efficiency: Concepts and ApplicationsReview of Economics and Statistics, 1987
- The Framing of Decisions and the Psychology of ChoiceScience, 1981
- Overconfidence in case-study judgments.Journal of Consulting Psychology, 1965