Silent versus oral reading comprehension and efficiency
- 2 January 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Psychology in the Schools
- Vol. 41 (2) , 241-246
Abstract
Seventy‐four students read passages from an individually administered test of reading comprehension (a subtest from the Test of Dyslexia, a test of reading and related abilities currently in development; McCallum & Bell, 2001), and then answered literal and inferential questions. Students were randomly assigned to one of two conditions; 39 students read the passages silently and 35 read orally, with time recorded for each passage read. Comprehension and time were dependent measures for a Multivariate Analysis of Covariance (MANCOVA) and two follow‐up Analyses of Covariance (ANCOVA). After controlling for reading ability, results from the MANCOVA showed a significant combined effect ( p < .05); however, a comparison of mean reading comprehension scores showed no significant difference between silent readers and oral readers ( p > .05). On the other hand, with reading ability controlled, silent readers took significantly less time to complete passages compared to those who read orally ( p < .02). In fact, students took 30% longer to read orally than silently, on average. When test directions do not specify either oral or silent reading and error analysis is not a goal, testing will be more efficient via silent responding with no loss of comprehension. © 2004 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Psychol Schs 41: 241–246, 2004.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Toward a Research-Based Assessment of DyslexiaJournal of Learning Disabilities, 2003
- "READ IN YOUR HEAD": A VYGOTSKIAN ANALYSIS OF THE TRANSITION FROM ORAL TO SILENT READINGReading Psychology, 2001
- EFFECTS OF STORY VERSUS PLAY GENRES ON THE COMPREHENSION OF HIGH, AVERAGE, AND LOW‐ACHIEVING JUNIOR HIGH READERSReading Psychology, 1992
- Relations among oral reading, silent reading and listening comprehension of students at differing competency levelsReading Research and Instruction, 1989
- Interactive Effects of Reading Mode, Production Format, and Structural Importance of Text among LD PupilsLearning Disability Quarterly, 1988
- Differences in Text Comprehension Amongst 7-8-Year-Old ChildrenSchool Psychology International, 1988
- The effect of four modes of reading on children's comprehensionReading Research and Instruction, 1986
- Differences in literal and inferential comprehension after reading orally and silently.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1985
- Oral Reading, Silent Reading, and Listening Comprehension: a Comparative StudyJournal of Reading Behavior, 1978