Breaking bad? Down and Dirty with Military Anthropology
- 17 December 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Ethnos
- Vol. 86 (4) , 676-693
Abstract
This article revisits the debate around the frequent problematisation of anthropological research on ‘our troops’ within the wider anthropology community. Engaging my research on Danish expeditionary forces and my fellow anthropologists’ disheartening responses to that research, this study examines controversies over military anthropology as a fundamental question of the apparent tension between empathy and critique. Drawing upon my uneasy experiences of ‘breaking bad’, in terms of becoming an ‘embedded anthropologist’ in a Danish combat unit, I argue that one answer as to why military anthropology tends to be frowned upon is to be found in failures to empathise as well as in different (mis)conceptions of empathy and critique. I show that ‘our troops’ and ‘their anthropologist’ are subjected to processes of othering at the limits of empathy, and I reflect on the trouble with empathy as a research tool and its consequences for a twenty-first-century military anthropology.Keywords
Funding Information
- Independent Research Fund Denmark
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Heroes Once AgainEthnos, 2017
- The endurance of critiqueAnthropological Theory, 2017
- Becoming a warring nation: the Danish ‘military moment’ and its repercussionsCritical Military Studies, 2016
- Fighting for the family: overcoming distances in time and spaceCritical Military Studies, 2016
- The ‘distant war’ up close and personal: approximating Afghanistan at the Danish Arsenal MuseumCritical Military Studies, 2016
- The Dark Side of Empathy: Mimesis, Deception, and the Magic of AlterityComparative Studies in Society and History, 2015
- Cruel Attachments2015
- The Risks of Scholarly Militarization: A Feminist AnalysisPerspectives on Politics, 2010
- Anthropology and MilitarismAnnual Review of Anthropology, 2007
- National Identity and Mentalities of War in Three EC CountriesJournal of Peace Research, 1993