Autism is characterized by difficulties in initiating and maintaining social interactions and communication, and displays reduced attention to faces, particularly in the eye region. Family members of autistic individuals are more likely to exhibit autism-like traits and also show reduced attention to the eye region during infancy. The current study tested 9-month-old infants (n = 47, 68.07% white) with (first-degree relatedness = 9, male = 55.56%, second-degree relatedness = 9, male = 66.67%) and without a familial history of autism (n= 29,male = 44.83%) for their preference for eyes, using side-by-side images of faces with open versus closed eyes. The same infants were later assessed longitudinally for autism-related characteristics. A stronger preference for open eyes predicted lower autism-related scores later in infants with a first-degree relative with autism. These findings provide valuable insights into how early eye preference may predict later autism outcomes in infants at elevated likelihood for autism.