Abstract
Background: The Caribbean sugar industry faces growing pressure to improve resource efficiency and meet global sustainability standards, yet no multi-year comparative studies exist for the Dominican Republic. Methods: This study examined six consecutive harvest seasons (2019/2020–2024/2025) across all three large-scale sugar mills in the eastern Dominican Republic—Central Romana, Cristóbal Colón, and Porvenir—covering the entire active milling capacity of the region. Official INAZUCAR production data were combined with estimated resource consumption indicators and qualitative insights from more than ten semi-structured interviews with production staff and operational managers. A two-factor ANOVA (Mill × Harvest Year) without replication, with Tukey HSD post hoc comparisons, was used to assess whether differences among mills were statistically significant. Results: Mill identity was the dominant driver of performance variation for both sugar production (F = 141.864, p < 0.0001, η2 = 0.948) and industrial yield (F = 37.348, p < 0.0001, η2 = 0.779). Central Romana maintains solid technical efficiency but has experienced sustained supply-side contraction since 2021/2022; Cristóbal Colón shows stable, consistent performance throughout the study period; Porvenir has deteriorated progressively, reaching a near-collapse of industrial yield (0.94%) in 2024/2025. Conclusions: These findings show that sustainability strategies cannot be applied uniformly across the sector and must be tailored to the specific structural conditions of each mill. Mill-specific approaches aligned with SDG 6, SDG 9, and SDG 12 are needed, offering empirical evidence previously unavailable for the Dominican and Caribbean context.