Impact of COVID-19-adapted guidelines using different airway management strategies on resuscitation quality in out-of-hospital-cardiac-arrest – a randomised manikin study
Authors:
- Sean S. ScholzSSSean S. Scholz
- Sissy LinderSLSissy Linder
- Eugen LatkaELEugen Latka
- Tobias BartnickTBTobias Bartnick
- Daniel KarlaDKDaniel Karla
- Daniel ThaemelDTDaniel Thaemel
- Marlena WolffMWMarlena Wolff
- Odile SauzetOSOdile Sauzet
- Sebastian W. RehbergSRSebastian W. Rehberg
- Karl-Christian ThiesKTKarl-Christian Thies
- Gerrit JansenGJGerrit Jansen
Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 23 (1) , 1-11
Abstract
Background: Although airway management for paramedics has moved away from endotracheal intubation towards extraglottic airway devices in recent years, in the context of COVID-19, endotracheal intubation has seen a revival. Endotracheal intubation has been recommended again under the assumption that it provides better protection against aerosol liberation and infection risk for care providers than extraglottic airway devices accepting an increase in no-flow time and possibly worsen patient outcomes. Methods: In this manikin study paramedics performed advanced cardiac life support with non-shockable (Non-VF) and shockable rhythms (VF) in four settings: ERC guidelines 2021 (control), COVID-19-guidelines using videolaryngoscopic intubation (COVID-19-intubation), laryngeal mask (COVID-19-Laryngeal-Mask) or a modified laryngeal mask modified with a shower cap (COVID-19-showercap) to reduce aerosol liberation simulated by a fog machine. Primary endpoint was no-flow-time, secondary endpoints included data on airway management as well as the participants‘ subjective assessment of aerosol release using a Likert-scale (0 = no release–10 = maximum release) were collected and statistically compared. Continuous Data was presented as mean ± standard deviation. Interval-scaled Data were presented as median and Q1 and Q3. Results: A total of 120 resuscitation scenarios were completed. Compared to control (Non-VF:11 ± 3 s, VF:12 ± 3 s) application of COVID-19-adapted guidelines lead to prolonged no-flow times in all groups (COVID-19-Intubation: Non-VF:17 ± 11 s, VF:19 ± 5 s;p ≤ 0.001; COVID-19-laryngeal-mask: VF:15 ± 5 s,p ≤ 0.01; COVID-19-showercap: VF:15 ± 3 s,p ≤ 0.01). Compared to COVID-19-Intubation, the use of the laryngeal mask and its modification with a showercap both led to a reduction of no-flow-time(COVID-19-laryngeal-mask: Non-VF:p = 0.002;VF:p ≤ 0.001; COVID-19-Showercap: Non-VF:p ≤ 0.001;VF:p = 0.002) due to a reduced duration of intubation (COVID-19-Intubation: Non-VF:40 ± 19 s;VF:33 ± 17 s; both p ≤ 0.01 vs. control, COVID-19-Laryngeal-Mask (Non-VF:15 ± 7 s;VF:13 ± 5 s;p > 0.05) and COVID-19-Shower-cap (Non-VF:15 ± 5 s;VF:17 ± 5 s;p > 0.05). The participants rated aerosol liberation lowest in COVID-19-intubation (median:0;Q1:0,Q3:2;p < 0.001vs.COVID-19-laryngeal-mask and COVID-19-showercap) compared to COVID-19-shower-cap (median:3;Q1:1,Q3:3 p < 0.001vs.COVID-19-laryngeal-mask) or COVID-19-laryngeal-mask (median:9;Q1:6,Q3:8). Conclusions: COVID-19-adapted guidelines using videolaryngoscopic intubation lead to a prolongation of no-flow time. The use of a modified laryngeal mask with a shower cap seems to be a suitable compromise combining minimal impact on no-flowtime and reduced aerosol exposure for the involved providers.Keywords
Funding Information
- Universität Bielefeld
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Viral dynamics in mild and severe cases of COVID-19The Lancet Infectious Diseases, 2020
- Barrier Enclosure during Endotracheal IntubationNew England Journal of Medicine, 2020
- N95 filtering facepiece respirators do not reliably afford respiratory protection during chest compression: A simulation studyThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2020
- Effect of a Strategy of a Supraglottic Airway Device vs Tracheal Intubation During Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest on Functional OutcomeJAMA, 2018
- Effect of a Strategy of Initial Laryngeal Tube Insertion vs Endotracheal Intubation on 72-Hour Survival in Adults With Out-of-Hospital Cardiac ArrestJAMA, 2018
- Association Between Tracheal Intubation During Adult In-Hospital Cardiac Arrest and SurvivalJAMA, 2017
- Chest Compression With Personal Protective Equipment During Cardiopulmonary ResuscitationMedicine, 2016
- Risk Factors for SARS Transmission from Patients Requiring Intubation: A Multicentre Investigation in Toronto, CanadaPLOS ONE, 2010
- The “delay effect” of donning a gown during cardiopulmonary resuscitation in a simulation modelCanadian Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2008
- Gas leakage and the laryngeal mask airway: A comparison with the tracheal tube and facemask during spontaneous ventilation using a circle breathing systemAnaesthesia, 1996