Differential Returns to Academic Preparation for English Learners: Evidence from New York City
Open Access
- 1 March 2025
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Teachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education
- Vol. 127 (3) , 129-144
Abstract
This article reconsiders the role of prior academic preparation as it relates to English learners’ access to advanced coursework in high school. Using longitudinal data from New York City ( n = 178,155), we test a set of interactions between middle school preparation—in the form of math achievement and advanced math and science coursework—and subgroups of English learners (ELs). We find that for all ELs, both components of prior preparation are significantly less predictive of college-preparatory STEM course-taking than for comparable non-ELs. We also find that ELs are less likely to benefit from enrollment in schools where the average prior preparation is higher. These findings problematize the common practice of controlling for prior achievement without permitting the effects to vary by subgroup—an approach that tends to overstate the role of prior academic preparation in explaining course-taking disparities in high school. This study thus provides evidence for a necessary analytic adjustment in a growing area of research, as well as the need for more attention on the high school transition for ELs’ access to STEM coursework.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- English Learners in STEM Subjects2018
- PATHWAYS TO AN ELITE EDUCATION: APPLICATION, ADMISSION, AND MATRICULATION TO NEW YORK CITY'S SPECIALIZED HIGH SCHOOLSEducation Finance and Policy, 2018
- Eligiendo Escuelas: English Learners and Access to School ChoiceEducational Policy, 2017
- Questioning the Long-Term English Learner Label: How Categorization Can Blind Us to Students’ AbilitiesTeachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education, 2015
- Gatekeepers of the American Dream: How teachers’ perceptions shape the academic outcomes of immigrant and language-minority studentsSocial Science Research, 2015
- When Special Education Trumps ESL: An Investigation of Service Delivery for ELLs with DisabilitiesCritical Inquiry in Language Studies, 2014
- “I’m Not Going to Be, Like, for the AP”American Educational Research Journal, 2014
- Effects of High School Course-Taking on Secondary and Postsecondary SuccessAmerican Educational Research Journal, 2012
- Explaining Gaps in Readiness for College-Level Math: The Role of High School CoursesEducation Finance and Policy, 2009
- The Path through Math: Course Sequences and Academic Performance at the Intersection of Race‐Ethnicity and GenderAmerican Journal of Education, 2006