Misrepresenting the multicultural nation
Authors:
- Eugene MclaughlinEMEugene Mclaughlin
- Sarah NealSNSarah Neal
- 1 September 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Studies
- Vol. 25 (3) , 155-174
Abstract
The Commission for the Future of Multi-Ethnic Britain was launched by Jack Straw in January 1998 to provide a blueprint for a progressive, multi-culturally constituted ‘post nation’. The long awaited Commission report – the Parekh report – was published two years later and was met by a torrent of negative news media coverage and government handwashing. Academics and policy makers working on sensitive issues of race, ethnicity, culture and national identity are still attempting to learn the lessons from the failure of the Parekh report to capture the national-popular imagination. A series of important research questions are raised in this article about the role of the media in public policy agenda-setting; the most significant being whether the negative news coverage and political response to the report signalled the end of New Labour's ‘post Lawrence’ attempts to re-imagine Britain as a twenty-first century multiethnic nation. In its account of the report's production to publication narrative, the article considers the continued power of the news media to confound and unsettle the plans of policy makers, academics, public relations companies and government ministers working on race matters. In the broader context in which the nature of the relationship between policy networks, social policy documents and the news media remains relatively under-scrutinised in both policy and media debates, the article explores how, and on what terms, policy makers can and do engage with the process of making race-related policy documents ‘known about’. Drawing on data collected through a qualitative study of the journey of the Parekh report into the public domain, this article analyses the news media strategy developed to launch and promote the report and reveals the limits of attempts to manage the news media. It argues that the report was destabilised not only by the news media and its political reception but by competing sets of demands that mystified the purpose of the Commission and its beneficiaries.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding Stuart Hall2004
- Media Representation of Research: The case of a review of ethnic minority educationBritish Educational Research Journal, 2003
- The Scarman Report, the Macpherson Report and the Media: How Newspapers Respond to Race-centred Social Policy InterventionsJournal of Social Policy, 2003
- Framing Public Life2001
- Spin Doctors in the United States, Great Britain, and GermanyThe International Journal of Press/Politics, 2001
- After the Stephen Lawrence ReportCritical Social Policy, 1999
- The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning1993