Validating nonverbal cues for assessing physician empathy in telemedicine: a Delphi study
Open Access
- 8 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Medical Education Online
- Vol. 30 (1) , 2497328
Abstract
Nonverbal communication is essential in physician-patient interaction, especially in telemedicine where verbal cues may be limited. This study aimed to identify and validate key nonverbal cues for assessing physician empathy in telemedicine consultations through a Delphi method. A three-round Delphi study was conducted from June to November 2022, involving various experts, including academics, healthcare professionals, AI/telemedicine researchers, industry professionals, and patients. Experts evaluated the importance, validity, and reliability of potential nonverbal cues. Consensus was determined based on median responses and expert scoring percentages, with statistical agreement and stability assessed using Kendall's coefficient of concordance (Kendall's W) and Wilcoxon signed-rank test. Analyses were conducted using SPSS, version 23.0 with significance set at p < 0.05. Of the 72 experts invited, 37 (51%) agreed to participate, with 35 completing the first round (95% completion rate). Eight significant nonverbal cues were identified in the first round, though one did not reach consensus. The second round obtained an 89% response rate (31/35), with three new cues introduced; one did not reach consensus. Round 3 achieved a 94% response rate (29/31), finalizing nine key cues: facial expression, eye contact, tone of voice, smiling, head nodding, body posture, hand gesture, distance, and environmental cues. Among these, facial expression, eye contact, and tone of voice were identified as the most crucial. Inter-expert agreement was statistically significant across all items with strong agreement on the importance (W = 0.739, p < 0.001), good agreement on their validity (W = 0.689, p < 0.001), and moderate agreement on their reliability (W = 0.452, p < 0.001). This study highlights the importance of specific nonverbal cues in telemedicine, particularly facial expression, eye contact, and tone of voice. It provides a validated foundation for developing tools to enhance physician-patient interactions and potentially improve health outcomes in telemedicine.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministry of Education [The Higher Education Sprout Project]; National Science and Technology Council (112-2410-H-038 -015-MY)
- Ministry of Education [The Higher Education Sprout Project]; National Science and Technology Council (113-2629-H-038-003)
- Taipei Medical University-Shuang Ho Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare (112FRP–08)
- British Council Women (WISF22-005)
- Academy of Medical Sciences’ ISPF Networking (NGR1\1961)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Norms of valence, arousal, dominance, and age of acquisition for 4,300 Dutch wordsBehavior Research Methods, 2012
- Doctor-patient communication: a review.2010
- Conceptual frameworks to illuminate and magnifyMedical Education, 2009
- Emotion recognition from expressions in face, voice, and body: The Multimodal Emotion Recognition Test (MERT).Emotion, 2009
- On the importance of nonverbal communication in the physician–patient interactionPatient Education and Counseling, 2007
- The Delphi technique in health sciences education researchMedical Teacher, 2005
- The Effects of Physician Empathy on Patient Satisfaction and ComplianceEvaluation & the Health Professions, 2004
- Telemedicine and doctor-patient communication: an analytical survey of the literatureJournal of Telemedicine and Telecare, 2001
- Research guidelines for the Delphi survey techniqueJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2000
- Facial and bodily cues of genuineness, empathy and warmthJournal of Clinical Psychology, 1968