MODELS OF CIVIL LIABILITY FOR THE UNLAWFUL USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE ECONOMY
Open Access
- 2 February 2026
- journal article
- Published by Brazilian Journals in Veredas do Direito
- Vol. 23 (4) , e234833
Abstract
The rapid development and widespread deployment of artificial intelligence outpace existing legislation and give rise to new legal challenges. This results in regulatory gaps across various sectors, including healthcare, transport, intellectual property, etc. In particular, uncertainty persists regarding the grounds for and subjects of civil liability for harm caused by the unlawful use of AI in the economic sphere. The objective of this study is to analyze possible models of civil liability for the use of AI in the economy. The research methodology included desk-based analysis of Russian and other legal sources, theoretical synthesis of the results, and an expert survey involving 41 specialists. Thus, a classification of civil liability models for the use of AI in the economy is proposed with due regard to the autonomy of AI systems and the fundamental principles of liability. Three core models are identified: the fault-based model, which treats AI as a tool; the risk-based model, which applies a liability regime for hazardous products; and the vicarious liability model, which attributes responsibility to the AI owner for the actions of an autonomous system. Expert assessment indicates that models grounded in the principle of risk and the vicarious liability model are the most preferable. It is also established that the main subject of liability is the person who commits unlawful acts using AI and gets benefit from them. Where many persons are involved, liability is joint and several, which necessitates the further improvement of legislation.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Implementing healthy eating principles for consumers in a digital farmers' market systemBIO Web of Conferences, 2024
- Experimental Legal Framework of Artificial Intelligence in Russia (the Example of Moscow)Gaps in Russian legislation, 2024
- Artificial Intelligence in Forensic Automotive ExpertiseGaps in Russian legislation, 2024
- Operational investigative activities of criminal investigation officers to identify stolen property in the context of digitalizationПолицейская и следственная деятельность, 2024
- The Legal Regulation of Artificial Intelligence Systems in Private International LawGaps in Russian legislation, 2023
- State Regulation of Digital Technologies for Sustainable Development and Territorial PlanningInternational Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning, 2023
- Increasing the competitiveness of future economists for work in industry 4.0Perpsectives of science and education, 2023
- Developing Methods for Assessing the Introduction of Smart Technologies into the Socio-Economic Sphere Within the Framework of Open InnovationInternational Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning, 2023
- Investigation and Seizure of Electronic Media in the Production of Investigative ActionsLaw, State and Telecommunications Review, 2021
- The Applicability of Artificial Intelligence in International LawJournal of East Asia and International Law, 2019