History is critical: Addressing the false dichotomy between historical inquiry and criticality
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 21 March 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Theory & Research in Social Education
- Vol. 50 (2) , 173-195
Abstract
This article discusses the false dichotomy between criticality and historical inquiry. We argue that adding “critical” to “historical inquiry” can be interpreted as something distinct, instead of integral, to historical inquiry. It can normalize the idea that historical thinking is not critical, which, in turn, upholds the illusion that historical inquiry research is not inherently ideological or political. It inadvertently reifies a false dichotomy that silos historical inquiry scholarship into two camps: one that is deemed political because it directly engages in criticality and another that is deemed apolitical because it claims objectivity. We make three assertions: historical inquiry is already critical; history education research and critical scholarship share common commitments; and historical thinking should embrace the tension and other forms of knowledge as necessary to developing as a field. We conceptualize this tension as a space of possibility that repairs the marginalization of and centers Black, Indigenous, Latinx, and Asian American knowledge.Keywords
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Critical Studies and Social Education: 40 Years ofTRSETheory & Research in Social Education, 2013
- The Social Construction of Gender and Sexuality: Learning from Two Spirit TraditionsThe Social Studies, 2013
- Critical Historical Thinking: When Official Narratives Collide With Other NarrativesMulticultural Perspectives, 2012
- More Than a Single Best Narrative: Collective History and the Transformation of Historical ConsciousnessCurriculum Inquiry, 2008
- Landing on the Wrong Note: The Price We Paid for BrownEducational Researcher, 2004
- What is to be Done in the Aftermath of Proposition 187?Theory & Research in Social Education, 1999
- Back to the Melting Pot? A Response to LemingTheory & Research in Social Education, 1992
- Diaspora Literacy and Consciousness in the Struggle Against Miseducation in the Black CommunityThe Journal of Negro Education, 1992
- On the Reading of Historical Texts: Notes on the Breach Between School and AcademyAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1991
- Discourse and Criticism in the Social Studies ClassroomTheory & Research in Social Education, 1982