Time reversal and the symplectic symmetry of the electron spin

Authors:
  • RFRebecca Flint
    Rebecca Flint
  • MDM. Dzero
    M. Dzero
  • PCP. Coleman
    P. Coleman

Abstract
In the search for new kinds of collective phenomena in quantum matter, the physicist is often frustrated by the absence of natural small parameters to develop controlled approximation schemes. A theoretical tool of proven utility in this situation is the ``large N'' expansion, which extracts the collective physics of the real world by mapping it onto a solvable universe where particles carry a very large number (N) of spin components. This is a kind of synthetic quantum mechanics where 1/N plays the role of Planck's constant and quantum fluctuations about the emergent order are systematically reintroduced as a power series in this ``small'' parameter. In practice, the extrapolation to finite $N$ is delicate, and an absolutely minimal requirement for success is that the large N limit respects key physical symmetries. Here we show that two vital discrete symmetries of electrons, the inversion of spin under time reversal, and the neutrality of spins under particle-hole transformations, are violated in a large class of 1/N expansions based on the SU(N) group. Loss of these symmetries means that the method can not consistently describe singlet superconductivity or frustrated antiferromagnetism. By identifying time reversal symmetry with the symplectic symmetry of the physical electron spin, we have developed a large N expansion that respects both time-reversal and particle-hole invariance of the electron spin operator. The utility of this approach is illustrated with two model applications to frustrated antiferromagnetism and heavy fermion superconductivity. We also show how our method provides the basis for a controlled large N expansion for the resonating valence bond theory of high temperature superconductivity.