The chapter explores the phenomenon of intuitive diagnostic decision-making in psychiatry through an interdisciplinary lens, focusing on the praecox feeling (PF), i.e., a clinician's immediate, pre-reflective sense of 'bizarreness' in encounters with patients with schizophrenia. The chapter also explores the related phenomena of intuitive apprehension of borderline personality disorder and autism spectrum condition (ASC). Drawing on predictive coding theory, phenomenological psychopathology, evolutionary psychology, and computational psychiatry, we argue that the intuitive recognition of mental illness arises from violations of clinicians' hierarchical social priors, manifesting as unresolved prediction errors. These discrepancies, often triggered by subtle socio-emotional or interactional anomalies, are not merely subjective impressions but reflect embodied and affective disruptions in expected intersubjective synchrony. Phenomenologically, PF marks a breakdown in typification and intercorporeal resonance, undermining the intuitive grasp of another's experiential world. Predictive coding frameworks align with this perspective, suggesting that clinicians' brains flag such violations as persistent social prediction errors, particularly salient in disorders characterized by disturbed affective attunement, impaired communicative reciprocity, or impaired mentalizing capacity. In borderline personality disorder, intense emotional demands and boundary violations elicit hypervigilance and spatial constriction in the clinician's experience. In autism, divergences in embodied empathy give rise to a pre-reflective 'sense of distinct communicative patterns. We also propose that PF may serve as an evolved clinical heuristic, i.e., one that is adaptive in ancestral environments for detecting deviations from social norms and refined through professional experience. However, it is vulnerable to cognitive biases and must be balanced with analytical reasoning and structured assessment. Ultimately, recognizing the diagnostic value of intuitive experiences fosters a more personalized psychiatry grounded in embodied cognition, affective resonance, and intersubjective understanding.