Sociomathematical Norms and Automated Proof Checking in Mathematical Education: Reflections and Experiences
Author:
Open Access
- 1 July 2024
- journal article
- Published by Claremont Colleges Library in Journal of Humanistic Mathematics
- Vol. 14 (2) , 27-59
Abstract
According to a widely held view, mathematical proofs are essentially (indications of) formal derivations, and thus in principle mechanically checkable (this view is defended, for example, by Azzouni [3]). This should in particular hold for the kind of simple proof exercises typically given to students of mathematics learning to write proofs. If that is so, then automated proof checking should be an attractive option for math education at the undergraduate level. An opposing view would be that mathematical proofs are social objects and that what constitutes a mathematical proof can thus not be separated from the social context in which it arises. In particular, such “sociomathematical norms” play a role in teaching situations, see, for example, Stephan [37]. There thus seems to be a tension between the inherent social nature of “natural” mathematical proofs and attempts at their automated verification. In this paper, we explore this tension both theoretically and on the basis of our experiences with developing the Diproche system, a program for the automated verification of natural language proofs in college-level introduction to proof classes (modelled after the example of the Naproche system by Cramer, Koepke et al. [14]) and its use at the Europa-Universität Flensburg during the winter term 2020/2021.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learning about Proof with the Theorem Prover LEAN: the Abundant Numbers TaskInternational Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education, 2021
- Learning Logic and Proof with an Interactive Theorem Prover2019
- A FORMAL PROOF OF THE KEPLER CONJECTUREForum of Mathematics, Pi, 2017
- Mathematics Professors’ Evaluation of Students’ Proofs: A Complex Teaching PracticeInternational Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education, 2016
- Sociomathematical Norms in Mathematics Education2014
- On Mathematicians' Different Standards When Evaluating Elementary ProofsTopics in Cognitive Science, 2013
- The Naproche Project Controlled Natural Language Proof Checking of Mathematical TextsLecture Notes in Computer Science, 2010
- System for Automated Deduction (SAD): A Tool for Proof Verification2007
- Social and sociomathematical norms in an advanced undergraduate mathematics courseThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2000
- The Death of ProofScientific American, 1993