Validating Benefit and Cost Estimates: The Case of Airbag Regulation
- 1 August 2002
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Risk Analysis
- Vol. 22 (4) , 803-811
Abstract
Preregulation estimates of benefits and costs are rarely validated after regulations are implemented. This article performs such a validation for the mandatory automobile airbag requirement. We found that the original 1984 model used to estimate benefits became invalid when 1997 values were input into that 1984 model. However, using a published 1997 cost‐effectiveness model, we demonstrate, by replacing the model inputs with the values from 1984, that the 1997 cost‐effectiveness ratios, based on real‐world crash data and tear‐down cost data, are less attractive than what would have been originally anticipated. The three most important errors in the 1984 input values are identified: the overestimation of airbag effectiveness, the overestimation of baseline fatality/injury rates, and the underestimation of manual safety belt use. This case study, which suggests that airbags are a reasonable investment in safety, shows that the regulatory analysis tools do not always produce findings that are biased against health, safety, and environmental regulation. Future validation studies of health, safety, and environmental regulation should focus on validation of benefit and risk estimates, areas where we found significant error, as well as on cost estimates.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing The Quality Of Regulatory Impact AnalysesSSRN Electronic Journal, 2000
- Validating analytical judgments: the case of the airbag's lifesaving effectivenessReliability Engineering & System Safety, 1999
- What Can We Learn from the Grand Policy Experiment? Lessons from SO2 Allowance TradingJournal of Economic Perspectives, 1998
- Reductions in deaths in frontal crashes among right front passengers in vehicles equipped with passenger air bags1997
- Going beyond the single number: Using probabilistic risk assessment to improve risk managementHuman and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal, 1996
- Injuries From Traffic Crashes: Meeting the ChallengeAnnual Review of Public Health, 1993
- Injuries from Traffic Crashes: Meeting the ChallengeAnnual Review of Public Health, 1993
- The High Cost and Low Efficacy of Weekly Viral Cultures for Pregnant Women with Recurrent Genital HerpesMedical Decision Making, 1989
- A Probabilistic Analysis of the Passive-Restraint QuestionRisk Analysis, 1984
- Auto Safety Regulation: An Analysis of Market FailureThe Bell Journal of Economics, 1981