Diagnosing malignant melanoma in ambulatory care: a systematic review of clinical prediction rules
Authors:
Open Access
Abstract
Objectives Malignant melanoma has high morbidity and mortality rates. Early diagnosis improves prognosis. Clinical prediction rules (CPRs) can be used to stratify patients with symptoms of suspected malignant melanoma to improve early diagnosis. We conducted a systematic review of CPRs for melanoma diagnosis in ambulatory care. Design Systematic review. Data sources A comprehensive search of PubMed, EMBASE, PROSPERO, CINAHL, the Cochrane Library and SCOPUS was conducted in May 2015, using combinations of keywords and medical subject headings (MeSH) terms. Study selection and data extraction Studies deriving and validating, validating or assessing the impact of a CPR for predicting melanoma diagnosis in ambulatory care were included. Data extraction and methodological quality assessment were guided by the CHARMS checklist. Results From 16 334 studies reviewed, 51 were included, validating the performance of 24 unique CPRs. Three impact analysis studies were identified. Five studies were set in primary care. The most commonly evaluated CPRs were the ABCD, more than one or uneven distribution of Colour, or a large (greater than 6 mm) Diameter (ABCD) dermoscopy rule (at a cut-point of >4.75; 8 studies; pooled sensitivity 0.85, 95% CI 0.73 to 0.93, specificity 0.72, 95% CI 0.65 to 0.78) and the 7-point dermoscopy checklist (at a cut-point of ≥1 recommending ruling in melanoma; 11 studies; pooled sensitivity 0.77, 95% CI 0.61 to 0.88, specificity 0.80, 95% CI 0.59 to 0.92). The methodological quality of studies varied. Conclusions At their recommended cut-points, the ABCD dermoscopy rule is more useful for ruling out melanoma than the 7-point dermoscopy checklist. A focus on impact analysis will help translate melanoma risk prediction rules into useful tools for clinical practice.Keywords
Funding Information
- Health Research Board (HRC/2014/1)
This publication has 82 references indexed in Scilit:
- Accuracy of SIAscopy for pigmented skin lesions encountered in primary care: development and validation of a new diagnostic algorithmBMC Dermatology, 2010
- A prospective cluster-randomized trial to implement the Canadian CT Head Rule in emergency departmentsCanadian Medical Association Journal, 2010
- Seven-point checklist for dermatoscopy: Performance during 10 years of prospective surveillance of patients at increased melanoma riskJournal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2010
- A systematic review of health-related quality of life in cutaneous melanomaAnnals of Oncology, 2009
- Recognition of skin malignancy by general practitioners: observational study using data from a population-based randomised controlled trialBritish Journal of Cancer, 2009
- Sensitivity, specificity, and diagnostic accuracy of three dermoscopic algorithmic methods in the diagnosis of doubtful melanocytic lesionsJournal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 2007
- Diagnosing and managing cutaneous pigmented lesions: Primary care physicians versus dermatologistsJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2006
- Meta-analysis of risk factors for cutaneous melanoma: III. Family history, actinic damage and phenotypic factorsEuropean Journal of Cancer, 2005
- Meta-analysis of risk factors for cutaneous melanoma: I. Common and atypical naeviEuropean Journal of Cancer, 2005
- Changing epidemiology of malignant cutaneous melanoma in Europe 1953–1997: Rising trends in incidence and mortality but recent stabilizations in Western Europe and decreases in ScandinaviaInternational Journal of Cancer, 2003