The Neutral—Niche Debate: A Philosophical Perspective
Open Access
- 3 February 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Acta Biotheoretica
- Vol. 60 (3) , 257-271
Abstract
Ecological communities around the world are under threat while a consensus theory of community structure remains elusive. In the last decade ecologists have struggled with two seemingly opposing theories: niche-based theory that explains diversity with species’ differences and the neutral theory of biodiversity that claims that much of the diversity we observe can be explained without explicitly invoking species’ differences. Although ecologists are increasingly attempting to reconcile these two theories, there is still much resistance against the neutral theory of biodiversity. Here we argue that the dispute between the two theories is a classic example of the dichotomy between philosophical perspectives, realism and instrumentalism. Realism is associated with specific, small-scale and detailed explanations, whereas instrumentalism is linked to general, large-scale, but less precise accounts. Recognizing this will help ecologists get both niche-based and neutral theories in perspective as useful tools for understanding biodiversity patterns.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Species coexistence in a variable worldEcology Letters, 2011
- Negative density dependence can offset the effect of species competitive asymmetry: A niche-based mechanism for neutral-like patternsJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2011
- Niche and neutral models predict asymptotically equivalent species abundance distributions in high-diversity ecological communitiesProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2010
- Niches and distributional areas: Concepts, methods, and assumptionsProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2009
- Species–area curves, neutral models, and long‐distance dispersalEcology, 2009
- Relaxing the zero-sum assumption in neutral biodiversity theoryJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2008
- The zero-sum assumption in neutral biodiversity theoryJournal of Theoretical Biology, 2007
- Demystifying the West, Brown & Enquist model of the allometry of metabolismFunctional Ecology, 2006
- TOWARD A METABOLIC THEORY OF ECOLOGYEcology, 2004
- Mechanisms of Maintenance of Species DiversityAnnual Review of Ecology and Systematics, 2000