Comments on history and mathematics regarded as combined educational tools
Authors:
- 1 February 1978
- journal article
- growth processes-and-formal-logic
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Mathematical Education in Science and Technology
- Vol. 9 (1) , 15-29
Abstract
Mathematics teaching has developed considerably over the past two decades, but the history of mathematics and its bearing on the learning of mathematics itself has been neglected. There is a need to open discussion on the nature and role of the history of mathematics, particularly in the light of the recently mounted Open University course which will provide many teachers with the opportunity of gaining knowledge of this field. The history of mathematics as an educational tool should not be conceived as a separate subject, but rather as infusing or permeating through the whole of mathematics. In this way it can alleviate some of the problems raised by the formal‐logical character of mathematical thinking. The nature of mathematics is primarily quantitative and formal‐logical, whereas history is predominantly causal (which includes formal‐logical). The essential difference between mathematics and history is the exclusion of chance factors (contingencies) from the former which renders it timeless, and the inclusion in the latter of contingent factors in order to uncover the structure of the historical process. It is important that the causal logic of history and the formal logic of mathematics be brought together into a dynamic unity in order to humanize mathematics and thus make it more accessible. Euclid and the euclidean system have been central to mathematical development up to modern times. But both the domination of, and the challenge to, euclidean postulates must be seen in the context of time, place and socio‐cultural circumstances. Euclideanism, together with Egyptian, Mesopotamian and other mathematical systems, often suffers from anachronistic distortion. While historical data have an absolute validity, the explanation of their existence is conditional. By this is meant that knowledge of the circumstances and limitations under which mathematical discoveries are made is integral to the access to, appreciation of and performance in mathematics. This is the true role of the history of mathematics in the teaching of the subject.Keywords
This publication has 1 reference indexed in Scilit:
- Pictorial Perception and CultureScientific American, 1972