Indicators as a means of communicating knowledge
Author:
- 1 January 2005
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in ICES Journal of Marine Science
- Vol. 62 (3) , 606-611
Abstract
Indicators represent the link between objectives and action in management. The identification of ecosystem indicators must therefore be embedded in the decision-making process. Fisheries management can only be effective if the measures are considered legitimate by stakeholders. The choice of indicators to guide management should not be evaluated from a technical perspective alone, but also in relation to their effectiveness in communicating knowledge. More specifically, indicators should serve as a communication bridge between different knowledge discourses. Reference is often made to “local ecological knowledge” as a source that should be integrated in the process for management to be legitimate. However, while extensive studies have been made on local ecological knowledge per se, few have addressed the issue of its integration into co-management institutions with research-based knowledge. The challenge is consequently to identify indicators that have both research-based validity and reflect features that correspond to stakeholder knowledge, while relating to shared understandings of objectives and actions. This challenge is discussed from a developing-countries perspective. Problems and possible ways forward are illustrated on the basis of experiences from a range of case studies of knowledge discourses regarding living aquatic resources in southeast Asia and southern Africa. The studies have shown that the different knowledge discourses, and candidate indicators therein, relating to a specific ecosystem may be identified and characterized. Often, however, such indicators will have very little in common across knowledge discourses, and the differences cannot be overcome through a simple translation process. The perspectives of formal research-based knowledge and of fishers differ systemically, reflecting the different interests and scales of observation between the two parties. Also, fishers focus on a wider agenda than research alone, on allocation problems and conflicts among users. Allocation/access issues must therefore be addressed as an integral aspect of an ecosystem approach if management is to be effective.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reference points and reference directions for size-based indicators of community structureICES Journal of Marine Science, 2005
- Review of indicators in fisheries management – a development perspectiveAfrican Journal of Marine Science, 2004
- Fisheries co-management—an institutional innovation? Lessons from South East Asia and Southern AfricaMarine Policy, 2004
- Science and the User Perspective2003
- The Fisheries Co-management Experience2003
- Measuring ppm With Tennis Shoes: Science and Locally Meaningful Indicators of Environmental QualitySociety & Natural Resources, 2000
- Marine and Coastal Protected Areas: A Guide for Planners and Managers2000
- Chaos, complexity and community management of fisheriesMarine Policy, 1994
- Mandated Science1988