EXPLAINING PLANT‐LEVEL DIFFERENCES IN MANUFACTURING OVERHEAD: STRUCTURAL AND EXECUTIONAL COST DRIVERS IN THE WORLD AUTO INDUSTRY
Authors:
- 1 December 1995
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Production and Operations Management
- Vol. 4 (4) , 312-334
Abstract
Using data from 62 automobile assembly plants worldwide, we examine the extent to which various structural cost drivers (plant scale, automation, and product mix complexity) and exe‐cutionalcost drivers (product manufacturability, management policies, and production practices) account for plant‐level differences in manufacturing overhead. Our analysis of structural drivers finds that overhead hours per vehicle are negatively associated with production volumes, consistent with economies of scale in overhead functions. However, automation appears to have little influence on overhead levels. Product mix complexity's effect on overhead requirements varies with the complexity's form and the plant's manufacturing capabilities. Option and parts complexity (measures of peripheral and intermediate product variety) both exhibit adverse effects on overhead, reflecting the considerable logistical, coordination, and supervisory challenges that accompany an increased number of parts and more complex manufacturing tasks. In contrast, model mix complexity (a measure of fundamental variety) appears to have little impact on direct or overhead labor requirements in auto assembly plants. Our analysis of executional drivers provides empirical support for the claim that advanced manufacturing practices such as the reduction of buffers, multiskilled production workers, and the use of teams can lower overhead costs. We also find preliminary evidence that the lower overhead costs in Japanese auto assembly plants are due primarily to the use of multiskilled work teams and the shifting of traditional overhead activities to production workers. Overall, our results indicate that manufacturing overhead is a function not only of the structural cost drivers that have dominated the academic literature but also of executional cost drivers that are harder to duplicate and therefore potentially more valuable for achieving competitive advantage.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- AN EXAMINATION OF THE INDIRECT PRODUCTIVITY GAINS FROM QUALITY IMPROVEMENTProduction and Operations Management, 1994
- Production systems without MRP: A lean time based designOmega, 1994
- A new productivity paradigm for competitive advantageStrategic Management Journal, 1992
- MANUFACTURING PROCESS TECHNOLOGY and SUPPORT STAFF COMPOSITION: AN EMPIRICAL VIEW OF INDUSTRY EVIDENCEProduction and Operations Management, 1992
- Manufacturing overhead cost driver analysisJournal of Accounting and Economics, 1990
- An Introduction to Bootstrap MethodsSociological Methods & Research, 1989
- Towards a theory of manufacturing overhead cost behavior: A conceptual and empirical analysisJournal of Operations Management, 1987
- Technology and Size as Determinants of the Organizational Structure of Japanese FactoriesAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1981
- Technology and Organization in ManufacturingAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1976
- Labor as a Quasi-Fixed FactorJournal of Political Economy, 1962