A Comparison of the Perceived Pictorial and Aesthetic Qualities of Original Paintings and Their Postcard Images
Authors:
- 1 July 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Empirical Studies of the Arts
- Vol. 22 (2) , 129-142
Abstract
Art trained and untrained participants evaluated postcard images of nine paintings by renowned artists on 16 measures of the compositions' physical and structural characteristics, novelty of content, and aesthetic qualities. These ratings were compared to those obtained by Locher et al. (2001) from individuals experiencing the original paintings in the galleries of the New York Metropolitan Museum of Art and from viewers of slide-projected and computer-generated images of the set of art stimuli. Analyses revealed significant differences in the judged hedonic properties of the originals as compared to the postcard images, whereas the pictorial qualities of the artworks were comparable for these two format conditions. This was the case for both art trained and untrained participants. Additionally, ratings on all measures were found not to differ reliably across the three reproduction formats (viz., postcard, slide, and computer images). Findings are discussed in terms of Locher et al.'s facsimile-accommodation hypothesis of picture perception.Keywords
This publication has 5 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Influence of Presentation Format and Viewer Training in the Visual Arts on the Perception of Pictorial and Aesthetic Qualities of PaintingsPerception, 2001
- Original Paintings versus Slide and Computer Reproductions: A Comparison of Viewer ResponsesEmpirical Studies of the Arts, 1999
- Measuring Presence in Virtual Environments: A Presence QuestionnairePRESENCE: Virtual and Augmented Reality, 1998
- A Measure of the Information Content of Visual Art Stimuli for Studies in Experimental AestheticsEmpirical Studies of the Arts, 1995
- Compositional Geometry in PicturesEmpirical Studies of the Arts, 1995