In 2008, a consultation was conducted in the East Midlands in the United Kingdom amongst people working in the area of Arts & Health. The focus of the consultation was on how Arts & Health workers conduct, report and disseminate research and evaluation. In addition to workers, participants of Arts & Health projects also contributed to the consultation process. The process included commissioning eight Arts & Health groups in the region to contribute to the consultation by arranging workshops with their staff and participants to elicit their views. In these days of health commissioners demanding evidence for the effectiveness of interventions, questions such as How do we produce evidence? What research methods are appropriate? were asked of participants. This article reports the findings from the consultation. There is much energy for evaluation and research and interest in becoming more equipped to conduct this aspect of the work. There is an opportunity for regional and local research to contribute to the development of Arts & Health theory. It is thought that evaluation and research should employ mixed methods but reflect the philosophy and ethos of the organizations.