Abstract
We use data on 5.7 million European options written on the S&P 500 index to test the risk neutrality assumption, whereby the market price of an option is equal to the discounted expected value of its final payoff. The framework for testing the hypothesis is a heteroscedastic regression model with discounted actual payoff at expiry as the dependent variable, and market price of the option as the independent variable. We apply the test separately to call and put options. In addition, as well as applying the test to the complete sample, we apply it separately to three different market regimes spanned by the sample period: a bear market; a sideways market; and a bull market. The fundamental assumption of option pricing is strongly rejected for put options, but almost accepted for call options. The results imply that writers of put options require a risk premium of around $21, but no such premium is required for writers of call options.