Subsidising silence: how policy ideas entrench Italy’s use of employment subsidies
Authors:
Open Access
- 23 April 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Social Policy
- Vol. 55 (4) , 1-26
Abstract
Italy’s active labour market policy (ALMP) regime is marked by a paradox: despite limited investment in training, job placement services, and direct job creation, the country allocates above-average resources to employment subsidies. While this subsidy-heavy approach is often explained by the structure of Italy’s low-skill, low-productivity economy, this article proposes a complementary explanation grounded in political economy. We argue that the dominance of employment subsidies reflects the influence of a powerful discourse promoted by business interests, which frames excessive labour costs as the core challenge of the Italian labour market. This narrative has steered policy decisions towards cost-reduction strategies, crowding out more transformative measures aimed at human capital development. To unpack these dynamics, we employ a mixed-method research design combining qualitative and quantitative text analysis. We map stakeholder narratives in national media using Natural Language Processing techniques (BERTopic) and analyse parliamentary debates to identify ideational drivers. Our findings reveal how business-driven narratives have driven policy preferences towards employment subsidies. The article makes three main contributions. First, it situates employment subsidies within Italian ALMP. Second, it demonstrates how ideas structure labour market interventions. Third, it introduces an innovative methodological approach that integrates computational text analysis with traditional qualitative methods.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Combined and distributional effects of EPL reduction and hiring incentives: an assessment using the Italian “Jobs Act”The Journal of Economic Inequality, 2023
- Lost in Categorisation? Employment Subsidies – Bringing the Beneficiaries Back InJournal of Social Policy, 2022
- The ParlaMint corpora of parliamentary proceedingsLanguage Resources and Evaluation, 2022
- Expanding Welfare State Borders: Trade Unions and the Introduction of Pro-Outsiders Social Policies in Italy and ArgentinaJournal of Social Policy, 2021
- A tale of comprehensive labor market reforms: Evidence from the Italian jobs actLabour Economics, 2019
- Varieties of Employment Subsidy Design: Theory and Evidence from Across EuropeJournal of Social Policy, 2019
- Comparative Social Policy Analysis and Active Labour Market Policy: Putting Quality before QuantityJournal of Social Policy, 2015
- Spurring Job Creation in Response to Severe Recessions: Reconsidering Hiring CreditsJournal of Policy Analysis and Management, 2012
- Great Transformations2002
- Political Analysis2002