The Dangers of Reading As We Know It: Sight Reading As a Source of Heresy in Early Rabbinic Traditions
- 31 January 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of the American Academy of Religion
- Vol. 85 (3) , 709-745
Abstract
Contemporary scholarship often treats classical rabbinic allusions to “reading” the Bible as evidence that late antique rabbinic culture valorized the written word as a source of religious knowledge and authority. However, the early rabbinic practice that we commonly refer to as “reading” actually consisted of reciting a precise oral formula from memory—with (or more often without) reference to a written text. When a rabbinic Jew “read” the Bible according to this practice, he did not extract words or meaning from written signs but rather pulled words and formulas from memory which could then be correlated with a written text for ritual performances. In contrast, classical rabbinic traditions treat the practices associated with acquiring information from written texts as an alien, even illicit, mode of engaging with written text and a locus of spiritual and social dangers.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Uncovering Covert Links between Halakhah and Aggadah in the Babylonian Talmud: The Talmudic Discussion of the Yom Kippur Afflictions in B. YomaAJS Review: The Journal of the Association for Jewish Studies, 2016
- Principles of Akkadian Textual Criticism2012
- The Scriptural Movement of Late Antiquity and Christian MonasticismJournal of Early Christian Studies, 2008
- Chapter Nine. ‘Uneducated’, ‘ignorant’, or even ‘illiterate’? Aspects and Background for an Understanding of Αγραμματοι (and Ιδιωται) in Acts 4:132007
- Chapter Seven. (IL)Literacy In Non-Literary Papyri From Graeco-Roman Egypt: Further Aspects To The Educational Ideal In Ancient Literary Sources And Modern Times2007
- Transmitting Mishnah2006
- Techniques of reading in classical antiquityThe Classical Quarterly, 1997
- Placing Reading: Ancient Israel and Medieval Europe1993
- Introduction1993
- THE NEW TESTAMENT IN THE MAKING1970