Discussions of US foreign policy are heavily influenced by what we term competing regions discourse—the idea that there is a competition for resources between different global regions. While this discourse makes some valid points, it underemphasizes how complementarities between different regions can further the foreign policy goals of the United States. Competing regions discourse also overemphasizes military power—especially in Europe, the Indo-Pacific and the Middle East—at the expense both of other regions and of softer tools of foreign policy. This policy paper puts forward a complementary conceptualization of regions in US foreign policy that highlights their interconnectedness: countries in one region can help the United States and its allies address problems in another region. This is essential to recognize at a time when adversaries of the US are increasingly engaging in cross-regional cooperation with each other. Rather than pursuing a unilateral or bilateral foreign policy predicated on the competing regions discourse, the second Trump administration could learn from its predecessor and pay heed to this potential for interregional complementarity. We argue that the Biden administration largely recognized and acted upon the complementary nature of the world's regions in its foreign policy. Allies of the US should stress the value of complementarity in making the case for multilateralism and seeking incremental changes in Trump's foreign policy. Researchers and policy-makers should focus on how the US and its allies can employ a variety of fungible tools to increase interregional cooperation and create a more resilient foreign policy.